/*! This file is auto-generated */ .wp-block-button__link{color:#fff;background-color:#32373c;border-radius:9999px;box-shadow:none;text-decoration:none;padding:calc(.667em + 2px) calc(1.333em + 2px);font-size:1.125em}.wp-block-file__button{background:#32373c;color:#fff;text-decoration:none} Problem 12 Give two reasons why the dual-pr... [FREE SOLUTION] | 91Ó°ÊÓ

91Ó°ÊÓ

Give two reasons why the dual-pricing system of transfer pricing is not widely used.

Short Answer

Expert verified
The dual-pricing system is complex to manage and can cause internal conflicts.

Step by step solution

01

Understanding Dual-Pricing System

The dual-pricing system in transfer pricing refers to the method where a product is priced differently for internal transfers within an organization compared to external sales. This method aims to motivate both the transferring and receiving divisions by using two sets of prices—one potentially at cost and the other at market value.
02

Reason 1: Increased Complexity

Implementing a dual-pricing system introduces significant complexity to the accounting and financial systems of a company. It requires maintaining two sets of financial records for each product in the transfer process, which can complicate the auditing process and make financial reporting more cumbersome.
03

Reason 2: Potential for Manipulation and Conflict

This system can lead to conflicts and manipulation as different divisions might have incentives to distort true costs to either inflate the profits of one division or depict lower costs in another. The conflicting objectives of divisions can create internal friction and affect the overall coherence and performance of the organization.

Unlock Step-by-Step Solutions & Ace Your Exams!

  • Full Textbook Solutions

    Get detailed explanations and key concepts

  • Unlimited Al creation

    Al flashcards, explanations, exams and more...

  • Ads-free access

    To over 500 millions flashcards

  • Money-back guarantee

    We refund you if you fail your exam.

Over 30 million students worldwide already upgrade their learning with 91Ó°ÊÓ!

Key Concepts

These are the key concepts you need to understand to accurately answer the question.

Transfer Pricing
Transfer pricing is a method used by companies to assign the value of goods and services transferred between divisions within the same organization. This process is crucial as it impacts the financial performance of each division and the organization as a whole.

It decides how profits are allocated among divisions, affecting both internal assessments and tax liabilities.
  • Sets benchmarks for division performance.
  • Aids in aligning division and company objectives.
  • Used in tax strategy to optimize tax payments overall.
Transfer pricing needs to be well-structured to avoid complications like tax audits and ensure compliance with international guidelines. One example of transfer pricing is the dual-pricing system, which uses different prices for internal transfers compared to external sales. Though innovative, this method has its challenges.
Internal Transfers
Internal transfers refer to the movement of goods, services, or funds between different divisions of a company. It's a common practice in large, diversified businesses looking to leverage internal efficiencies and expertise.

With internal transfers, it’s crucial to evaluate at what cost these transfers occur, as it impacts division profitability and performance measurement.
  • Facilitates optimal resource sharing.
  • Can enhance cooperation and synergy among divisions.
  • Requires careful pricing to maintain fairness and transparency.
The dual-pricing method adds a layer of complexity to internal transfers by using two distinct prices for transactions, which can help align division goals more closely with market realities.
Financial Complexity
Financial complexity arises in dual-pricing systems due to the need for managing multiple pricing records for a single product. Each division might record these prices differently, complicating financial tracking.

Setting two price records – one for internal transfers and another for external sales, increases the volume of data to be managed and controlled.
  • Increases auditing time and costs.
  • Requires advanced accounting systems to track and reconcile prices.
  • Compounds financial statement preparation and analysis.
These complexities make it cumbersome for organizations to maintain clear and precise financial records, sometimes preventing companies from adopting dual-pricing.
Division Conflict
Division conflict can occur in a dual-pricing system as divisions within a company may have conflicting objectives. This typically happens when the incentives created by dual-pricing lead managers to prioritize division performance over overall corporate goals.

Managers might manipulate costs or revenues to enhance their division’s financial outlook, straining inter-division relationships.
  • Creates a competitive rather than cooperative atmosphere.
  • May lead to mistrust within the organization.
  • Risk of misalignment between division and company objectives.
These conflicts can be detrimental to a company's coherence and operational effectiveness, hindering its ability to achieve strategic objectives.

One App. One Place for Learning.

All the tools & learning materials you need for study success - in one app.

Get started for free

Most popular questions from this chapter

The Allison-Chambers Corporation, manufacturer of tractors and other heavy farm equipment, is organized along decentralized product lines, with each manufacturing division operating as a separate profit center. Each division manager has been delegated full authority on all decisions involving the sale of that division's output both to outsiders and to other divisions of Allison- Chambers. Division \(C\) has in the past always purchased its requirement of a particular tractor-engine component from division A. However, when informed that division \(A\) is increasing its selling price to \(\$ 150,\) division C's manager decides to purchase the engine component from external suppliers. 1\. Assume that there are no alternative uses for internal facilities of division A. Determine whether the com pany as a whole will benefit if divisision C purchases the component from external suppliers for \(\$ 135\) per unit What should the transfer price for the component be set at so that division managers acting in their own divisisions' best interests take actions that are also in the bestinterest of the company as a whole? 2\. Assume that internal facilities of division A would not otherwise be idle. By not producing the 1,000 units for division C, divisision A's equipment and other facilities would be used for other production operations that would result in annual cash-operating savings of \(\$ 18,000\). Should division C purchase from external suppliers? Show your computations. 3\. Assume that there are no alternative uses for division A's internal facilitites and that the price from out siders drops \(\$ 20 .\) Should division C purchase from external suppliers? What should the transfer price for the component be set at so that division managers acting in their own divisisions' best interests take actions that are also in the best interest of the company as a whole?

(J. Patell, adapted) The California Instrument Company (CIC) consists of the semiconductor division and the process-control division, each of which operates as an independent profit center. The semiconductor division employs craftsmen who produce two different electronic components: the new high- performance Super-chip and an older product called Okay-chip. These two products have the following cost characteristics: $$\begin{array}{lcc} & \text { Super-chip } & \text { Okay-chip } \\ \hline \text { Direct materials } & \$ 5 & \$ 2 \\ \text { Direct manufacturing labor, 3 hours } \times \$ 20 ; 1 \text { hour } \times \$ 20 & 60 & 20 \end{array}$$ Due to the high skill level necessary for the craftsmen, the semiconductor division's capacity is set at 45,000 hours per year. Maximum demand for the Super-chip is 15,000 units annually, at a price of \(\$ 80\) per chip. There is unlimited demand for the Okay-chip at \(\$ 26\) per chip. The process-control division produces only one product, a process-control unit, with the following cost structure: The current market price for the control unit is \(\$ 132\) per unit. A joint research project has just revealed that a single Super-chip could be substituted for the circuit board currently used to make the process-control unit. Direct labor cost of the process-control unit would be unchanged. The improved process-control unit could be sold for \(\$ 145\) 1\. Calculate the contribution margin per direct-labor hour of selling Super- chip and Okay-chip. If no transfers of Super-chip are made to the process- control division, how many Super-chips and Okay-chips should the semiconductor division manufacture and sell? What would be the division's's annual contribution margin? Show your computations. 2\. The process-control division expects to sell 5,000 process-control units this year. From the viewpoint of California Instruments as a whole, should 5,000 Super-chips be transferred to the process-control division to replace circuit boards? Show your computations 3\. What transfer price, or range of prices, would ensure goal congruence among the division managers? Show your calculations. 4\. If labor capacity in the semiconductor division were 60,000 hours instead of \(45,000,\) would your answer to requirement 3 differ? Show your calculations

Jackson Markets, a chain of traditional supermarkets, is interested in gaining access to the organic and health food retail market by acquiring a regional company in that sector. Jackson intends to operate the newly-acquired stores independently from its supermarkets. One of the prospects is Health Source, a chain of twenty stores in the mid- Atlantic. Buying for all twenty stores is done by the company's central office. Store managers must follow strict guidelines for all aspects of store management in an attempt to maintain consistency among stores. Store managers are evaluated on the basis of achieving profit goals developed by the central office. The other prospect is Harvest Moon, a chain of thirty stores in the Northeast. Harvest Moon managers are given significant flexibility in product offerings, allowing them to negotiate purchases with local organic farmers. Store managers are rewarded for exceeding self-developed return on investment goals with company stock options. Some managers have become significant shareholders in the company, and have even decided on their own to open additional store locations to improve market penetration. However, the increased autonomy has led to competition and price cutting among Harvest Moon stores within the same geographic market, resulting in lower margins. 1\. Would you describe Health Source as having a centralized or a decentralized structure? Explain. 2\. Would you describe Harvest Moon as having a centralized or a decentralized structure? Discuss some of the benefits and costs of that type of structure. 3\. Would stores in each chain be considered cost centers, revenue centers, profit centers, or investment centers? How does that tie into the evaluation of store managers? 4\. Assume that Jackson chooses to acquire Harvest Moon. What steps can Jackson take to improve goal congruence between store managers and the larger company?

"Organizations typically adopt a consistent decentralization or centralization philosophy across all their business functions." Do you agree? Explain.

Describe three criteria you would use to evaluate whether a management control system is effective.

See all solutions

Recommended explanations on Math Textbooks

View all explanations

What do you think about this solution?

We value your feedback to improve our textbook solutions.

Study anywhere. Anytime. Across all devices.