/*! This file is auto-generated */ .wp-block-button__link{color:#fff;background-color:#32373c;border-radius:9999px;box-shadow:none;text-decoration:none;padding:calc(.667em + 2px) calc(1.333em + 2px);font-size:1.125em}.wp-block-file__button{background:#32373c;color:#fff;text-decoration:none} Problem 60 In December 2001, the Department... [FREE SOLUTION] | 91影视

91影视

Log out

Learning Materials

Features

Discover

Chapter 11: Problem 60

In December 2001, the Department of Veterans Affairs announced that it would begin paying benefits to soldiers suffering from Lou Gehrig's disease who had served in the Gulf War (The New York Times, December 11,2001 ). This decision was based on an analysis in which the Lou Gehrig's disease incidence rate (the proportion developing the disease) for the approximately 700,000 soldiers sent to the Gulf between August 1990 and July 1991 was compared to the incidence rate for the approximately \(1.8\) million other soldiers who were not in the Gulf during this time period. Based on these data, explain why it is not appropriate to perform a formal inference procedure (such as the two-sample \(z\) test) and yet it is still reasonable to conclude that the incidence rate is higher for Gulf War veterans than for those who did not serve in the Gulf War.

Short Answer

Expert verified
Formal inference procedures like the two-sample z test are not appropriate in this case because they are designed to estimate parameters of a population from a sample. Here, we are not dealing with samples but with entire populations of soldiers. Therefore, we are not estimating but comparing known parameters. Further, the incidence rate is a ratio, so a higher rate among Gulf War veterans would directly indicate a higher risk of developing the disease in this group.

Step by step solution

01

Understanding Data

First, let's understand the exercise. It deals with two groups - soldiers who served in the Gulf War (700,000) and other soldiers who did not (1.8 million). The incidence rate of Lou Gehrig's disease was compared between these groups.
02

Why not Formal Inference

The reason it's not appropriate to perform a formal inference here is that formal tests like two-sample z test are designed to infer from a sample to a population. Here, we are not dealing with samples. The incidence rates are for the entire populations of soldiers who were, and were not, in the Gulf War during the specified time period. We are not estimating an unknown parameter based on a sample but rather comparing known parameters derived from entire populations.
03

How to Conclude Higher Incidence Rate

Despite this, we can still conclude that the incidence rate is higher for Gulf War veterans because we are comparing the incidence rates (a ratio of disease frequency to the group size) for the entire groups. If the ratio is higher for the Gulf War veterans, then it is reasonable to conclude that these veterans had a higher risk of developing the disease.

Unlock Step-by-Step Solutions & Ace Your Exams!

  • Full Textbook Solutions

    Get detailed explanations and key concepts

  • Unlimited Al creation

    Al flashcards, explanations, exams and more...

  • Ads-free access

    To over 500 millions flashcards

  • Money-back guarantee

    We refund you if you fail your exam.

Over 30 million students worldwide already upgrade their learning with 91影视!

One App. One Place for Learning.

All the tools & learning materials you need for study success - in one app.

Get started for free

Most popular questions from this chapter

The article "Movement and Habitat Use by Lake Whitefish During Spawning in a Boreal Lake: Integrating Acoustic Telemetry and Geographic Information Systems" (Transactions of the American Fisheries Society, [1999]: \(939-952\) ) included the accompanying data on weights of 10 fish caught in 1995 and 10 caught in \(1996 .\) \(\begin{array}{lllllllllll}1995 & 776 & 580 & 539 & 648 & 538 & 891 & 673 & 783 & 571 & 627\end{array}\) \(\begin{array}{lllllllllll}1996 & 571 & 627 & 727 & 727 & 867 & 1042 & 804 & 832 & 764 & 727\end{array}\) Is it appropriate to use the independent samples \(t\) test to compare the mean weight of fish for the 2 years? Explain why or why not.

The positive effect of water fluoridation on dental health is well documented. One study that validates this is described in the article "Impact of Water Fluoridation on Children's Dental Health: A Controlled Study of Two Pennsylvania Communities" (American Statistical Association Proceedings of the Social Statistics Section \([1981]:\) 262-265). Two communities were compared. One had adopted fluoridation in 1966, whereas the other had no such program. Of 143 randomly selected children from the town without fluoridated water, 106 had decayed teeth, and 67 of 119 randomly selected children from the town with fluoridated water had decayed teeth. Let \(\pi_{1}\) denote the true proportion of children drinking fluoridated water who have decayed teeth, and let \(\pi_{2}\) denote the analogous proportion for children drinking unfluoridated water. Estimate \(\pi_{1}-\pi_{2}\) using a \(90 \%\) confidence interval. Does the interval contain \(0 ?\) Interpret the interval.

British health officials have expressed concern about problems associated with vitamin D deficiency among certain immigrants. Doctors have conjectured that such a deficiency could be related to the amount of fiber in a person's diet. An experiment was designed to compare the vitamin D plasma half-life for two groups of healthy individuals. One group was placed on a normal diet, whereas the second group was placed on a high-fiber diet. The accompanying table gives the resulting data (from "Reduced Plasma Half-Lives of Radio-Labeled \(25(\mathrm{OH}) \mathrm{D} 3\) in Subjects Receiving a High-Fibre Diet," British Journal of Nutrition [1993]: 213-216). \(\begin{array}{lllllll}\text { Normal diet } & 19.1 & 24.0 & 28.6 & 29.7 & 30.0 & 34.8\end{array}\) \(\begin{array}{llllllll}\text { High-fiber diet } & 12.0 & 13.0 & 13.6 & 20.5 & 22.7 & 23.7 & 24.8\end{array}\) Use the following MINITAB output to determine whether the data indicate that the mean half-life is higher for those on a normal diet than those on a high- fiber diet. Assume that treatments were assigned at random and the two plasma half-life distributions are normal. Test the appropriate hypotheses using \(\alpha=.01 .\) Two-sample \(\mathrm{T}\) for normal vs high Iw \(\begin{array}{lccrr} & \mathrm{N} & \text { Mean } & \text { StDev } & \text { SE Mean } \\ \text { Normal } & 6 & 27.70 & 5.44 & 2.2 \\ \text { High } & 7 & 18.61 & 5.55 & 2.1\end{array}\) \(5.2\) 15 High \(95 \%\) C.l. for mu normal - mu high: \((2.3,15.9)\) T-Test mu normal = mu high(vs >):T \(=2.97 \mathrm{P}=0.0070 \mathrm{DF}=10\)

Breast feeding sometimes results in a temporary loss of bone mass as calcium is depleted in the mother's body to provide for milk production. The paper "Bone Mass Is Recovered from Lactation to Postweaning in Adolescent Mothers with Low Calcium Intakes" (American Journal of Clinical Nutrition [2004]: \(1322-1326\) ) gave the following data on total body bone mineral content \((\mathrm{g})\) for a sample of mothers both during breast feeding (B) and in the postweaning period (P). Do the data suggest that true average total body bone mineral content during postweaning exceeds that during breast feeding by more than \(25 \mathrm{~g}\) ? State and test the appropriate hypotheses using a significance level of \(.05\). \(\begin{array}{lllllll}\text { Subject } & 1 & 2 & 3 & 4 & 5 & 6 \\ \text { B } & 1928 & 2549 & 2825 & 1924 & 1628 & 2175 \\ \text { P } & 2126 & 2885 & 2895 & 1942 & 1750 & 2184 \\ \text { Subject } & 7 & 8 & 9 & 10 & & \\ \text { B } & 2114 & 2621 & 1843 & 2541 & & \\ \text { P } & 2164 & 2626 & 2006 & 2627 & & \end{array}\)

The article "A 'White' Name Found to Help in Job Search" (Associated Press, January 15,2003 ) described in experiment to investigate if it helps to have a "whitesounding" first name when looking for a job. Researchers sent 5000 resumes in response to ads that appeared in the Boston Globe and Chicago Tribune. The resumes were identical except that 2500 of them had "white- sounding" first names, such as Brett and Emily, whereas the other 2500 had "black-sounding" names such as Tamika and Rasheed. Resumes of the first type elicited 250 responses and resumes of the second type only 167 responses. Do these data support the theory that the proportion receiving positive responses is higher for those resumes with "whitesounding first" names?
See all solutions

Recommended explanations on Math Textbooks

Applied Mathematics

Read Explanation

Probability and Statistics

Read Explanation

Decision Maths

Read Explanation

Geometry

Read Explanation

Mechanics Maths

Read Explanation

Theoretical and Mathematical Physics

Read Explanation
View all explanations

What do you think about this solution?

We value your feedback to improve our textbook solutions.

Study anywhere. Anytime. Across all devices.