/*! This file is auto-generated */ .wp-block-button__link{color:#fff;background-color:#32373c;border-radius:9999px;box-shadow:none;text-decoration:none;padding:calc(.667em + 2px) calc(1.333em + 2px);font-size:1.125em}.wp-block-file__button{background:#32373c;color:#fff;text-decoration:none} Problem 90 Acute OTM early in infancy may b... [FREE SOLUTION] | 91Ó°ÊÓ

91Ó°ÊÓ

Acute OTM early in infancy may be an important predictor of subsequent morbidity, including psychological and educational difficulties. A study was performed among high-risk infants who had already experienced either a single episode of acute OTM prior to the age of 6 months or two or more episodes before 12 months of life [23] Children were randomized to one of three treatment groups, (a) amoxicillin (AMX), (b) sulfisoxazole (SUL), or (c) placebo (PLA), and their parents were told to administer the drug daily for a 6 -month period (even in the absence of symptoms). If children had an acute OTM episode during the study period, they received the best antibiotic care, regardless of their study-drug group. The results were as shown in Table 10.36 What test can be used to compare the percentage of children who were acute OTM-free between the AMX group and the PLA group?

Short Answer

Expert verified
A Z-test for comparing two proportions can be used to compare the percentage of OTM-free children between the AMX group and the PLA group.

Step by step solution

01

Identify the type of data

The scenario involves comparing the percentage of children who were acute OTM-free between two groups: those who received amoxicillin (AMX) and those who received a placebo (PLA). The data is categorical, as we are comparing proportions.
02

Select the appropriate statistical test

When comparing proportions between two independent groups, a common statistical test used is the Chi-Square Test for Independence. However, if there are only two categories (success or failure, such as being OTM-free or not), a more appropriate test could be the Fisher's Exact Test or the Z-test for comparing two proportions, particularly when sample sizes are large and assumptions of normality are met.
03

Determine the size of the sample

To decide between using Fisher's Exact Test or the Z-test for proportions, consider the sample size. If the sample sizes in each group are small, Fisher's Exact Test is preferred due to its exactness. If the sample size is large enough for the approximation to be reliable, the Z-test for proportions can be used.
04

Making the decision

Typically, in medical studies with large sample sizes, the Z-test could be applied to compare the proportions unless the exact test is specified. Here, we will choose the Z-test for proportions assuming the study was large.

Unlock Step-by-Step Solutions & Ace Your Exams!

  • Full Textbook Solutions

    Get detailed explanations and key concepts

  • Unlimited Al creation

    Al flashcards, explanations, exams and more...

  • Ads-free access

    To over 500 millions flashcards

  • Money-back guarantee

    We refund you if you fail your exam.

Over 30 million students worldwide already upgrade their learning with 91Ó°ÊÓ!

Key Concepts

These are the key concepts you need to understand to accurately answer the question.

Statistical Testing
Statistical testing is a fundamental concept in biostatistics that helps us understand differences and relationships within a dataset. In this exercise, we are interested in comparing the proportions of children who were free from acute otitis media (OTM) between two groups - those receiving amoxicillin (AMX) and those given a placebo (PLA). By conducting a statistical test, we aim to determine if the differences in proportions observed are significant or could have occurred due to random chance.

When comparing proportions between two independent groups, you might consider tests such as the Chi-Square Test for Independence, which can let you know if there's a relationship between two categorical variables. However, specific scenarios call for more precise tests. In this case, with two outcome categories (OTM-free or not), the decision might lean towards using Fisher's Exact Test or the Z-test for proportions, particularly based on sample size considerations.
Categorical Data Analysis
Categorical data analysis involves handling and interpreting data that can be divided into distinct categories. In our example, categorical data refers to whether a child was OTM-free or not in each group. The main goal of this type of analysis is to check for associations and differences between the groups.

In this study, the data is categorical because we're recording whether children remained OTM-free (success) or not (failure). Such data can be summarized in contingency tables, representing frequencies of this binary outcome across different treatment groups (AMX vs. PLA). Understanding how to handle and analyze categorical data is crucial in biostatistics, as it forms the basis for understanding the distribution of outcomes and their relationships to treatment variants.
Comparing Proportions
When comparing proportions from different groups, you want to evaluate whether there's a notable difference in the occurrence of a particular outcome between these groups. This is essential in understanding the effectiveness of different treatments, like amoxicillin versus a placebo in preventing OTM.

To compare proportions effectively, various tests can be employed:
  • Z-test for Proportions: Ideal for large samples, this test helps assess whether the observed difference between groups is statistically significant.
  • Fisher's Exact Test: Often used when sample sizes are smaller, since it doesn’t rely on large sample approximations.
The decision between these tests often rests on sample size. Larger sample sizes typically allow for the Z-test, which is both simpler and quicker to execute, while smaller samples might necessitate the more meticulous Fisher's Exact Test. Understanding the context and sample characteristics helps in selecting the correct approach for comparing proportions.

One App. One Place for Learning.

All the tools & learning materials you need for study success - in one app.

Get started for free

Most popular questions from this chapter

A study was performed to look at the preference of different species of birds for different types of sunflower seeds. Two bird feeders were set up with different types of sunflower seeds, one with a black oil seed and one with a striped seed. The bird feeders were observed for a 1 -hour period for each of 12 days over a 1 -month period. The number of birds of different species who ate seeds from a specific bird feeder was counted for each bird feeder for each of a number of species of birds. (The data for this problem were supplied by David Rosner.) On the first day of testing, 1 titmouse ate the black oil seeds and 4 titmice ate the striped seeds. Of the goldfinches, 19 ate the black oil seeds and 5 ate the striped seeds. What test can be performed to assess whether the feeding preferences of titmice and goldfinches are comparable on the first day of testing?

A case-control study was performed among 145 subjects with macular degeneration and 34 controls, all of whom were \(70-\) to 79 -year-old women. A genetic risk score was developed to help differentiate the cases from the controls. The risk score was categorized into six groups \((1,2,3,4,\) 5, 6), with 6 being the highest risk and 1 being the lowest risk. The data in Table 10.48 were obtained relating the risk score to case/control status. What is the relative risk for AMD among women in group 6 compared with women in group \(1 ?\) What does the relative risk mean in words?

Suppose researchers do an epidemiologic investigation of people entering a sexually transmitted disease clinic. They find that 160 of 200 patients who are diagnosed as having gonorrhea and 50 of 105 patients who are diagnosed as having nongonococcal urethritis have had previous episodes of urethritis. Are the present diagnosis and prior episodes of urethritis associated?

A case-control study was performed among 145 subjects with macular degeneration and 34 controls, all of whom were \(70-\) to 79 -year-old women. A genetic risk score was developed to help differentiate the cases from the controls. The risk score was categorized into six groups \((1,2,3,4,\) 5, 6), with 6 being the highest risk and 1 being the lowest risk. The data in Table 10.48 were obtained relating the risk score to case/control status. What test can be performed to study the association between case/control status and risk score? Specifically, we are interested in testing whether cases tend to have consistently higher risk scores or consistently lower risk scores than controls.

Nighttime bladder control is an important developmental milestone, with failure dependent on age. Continence is usually achieved between 4 and 6 years of age, but an important minority of children experience delays in success. A longitudinal study was conducted in Britain in which nighttime bedwetting was assessed at ages \(4,6,8,9,11,\) and 15 years among 3272 children in the Medical Research Council's 1946 National Survey of Health [21]. The following data were presented. There were 1362 boys and 1313 girls who reported no bedwetting at any of the six ages just listed. Consider this as the control group. There were 6 boys and 2 girls who reported no bedwetting at ages \(4,6,\) and 8 but reported some bedwetting at both ages 9 and \(11 .\) Consider this as the case group. Ignore children with any other pattern of bedwetting over the six ages. What test can be used to assess whether the percentage of cases among boys is significantly different from the percentage of cases among girls?

See all solutions

Recommended explanations on Math Textbooks

View all explanations

What do you think about this solution?

We value your feedback to improve our textbook solutions.

Study anywhere. Anytime. Across all devices.