/*! This file is auto-generated */ .wp-block-button__link{color:#fff;background-color:#32373c;border-radius:9999px;box-shadow:none;text-decoration:none;padding:calc(.667em + 2px) calc(1.333em + 2px);font-size:1.125em}.wp-block-file__button{background:#32373c;color:#fff;text-decoration:none} Problem 68 In the United States, the median... [FREE SOLUTION] | 91Ó°ÊÓ

91Ó°ÊÓ

In the United States, the median age of residents is lowest in Utah. At each age level, the death rate from heart disease is higher in Utah than in Colorado. Overall, the death rate from heart disease is lower in Utah than Colorado. Are there any contradictions here, or is this possible? Explain.

Short Answer

Expert verified
It is possible due to Simpson's Paradox, where Utah's younger demographic lowers its overall heart disease death rate, despite higher age-specific rates.

Step by step solution

01

Identify Key Information

The problem provides three pieces of information about Utah and Colorado. First, Utah has the lowest median age of residents in the U.S. Second, at each age level, the death rate from heart disease is higher in Utah than in Colorado. Third, overall, Utah has a lower death rate from heart disease than Colorado. We need to examine how these facts can coexist.
02

Understand Median Age Impact

The median age being lower in Utah implies that Utah has a younger population compared to other states. A younger population typically experiences fewer age-related diseases like heart disease, which can lead to a lower overall death rate from such conditions.
03

Analyze Death Rate per Age Group

Even though at each age level, the death rate from heart disease is higher in Utah, the older age groups (which are more likely in Colorado due to the higher median age) contribute more significantly to the overall death rate statistics. This means more deaths from heart disease occur in Colorado, moving its overall rate higher.
04

Use Simpson's Paradox Explanation

The scenario described can be explained by Simpson's Paradox. This paradox occurs when a trend seems to appear in different groups of data disappears or reverses when these groups are combined. Utah's overall lower rate of heart disease deaths despite higher age-specific rates can occur because the effect of a younger population outweighs individual age group comparisons.

Unlock Step-by-Step Solutions & Ace Your Exams!

  • Full Textbook Solutions

    Get detailed explanations and key concepts

  • Unlimited Al creation

    Al flashcards, explanations, exams and more...

  • Ads-free access

    To over 500 millions flashcards

  • Money-back guarantee

    We refund you if you fail your exam.

Over 30 million students worldwide already upgrade their learning with 91Ó°ÊÓ!

Key Concepts

These are the key concepts you need to understand to accurately answer the question.

Understanding Median Age
The median age is the age at which half of the population is younger and the other half is older. It's a way to describe the age distribution of a population.

Utah is known for having the lowest median age in the United States. This means that its population is generally younger compared to other states, like Colorado. A younger population usually experiences fewer chronic illnesses, such as heart disease, that predominantly affect older adults.

Therefore, even if the younger groups in Utah have a higher death rate in specific age categories, their overall risk exposure is lower because the population is predominantly young. This naturally lowers the overall death rate from heart disease in Utah compared to Colorado.
Decoding Death Rate
The death rate is a measurement of the number of deaths in a particular population, scaled to the size of that population, per unit of time. For heart disease, this rate tells us how common heart disease-related deaths are within the population.

In this context, Utah shows higher death rates from heart disease at specific age levels when compared to Colorado. However, Utah's advantage is in its demographics. With fewer older adults who are significantly more at risk, this can translate to an overall lower statewide death rate from heart disease.

Therefore, understanding death rates involves looking beyond raw numbers to see how age distributions and other demographic factors influence these statistics.
Heart Disease and Its Impact
Heart disease remains one of the leading causes of death worldwide. Factors such as age, lifestyle, and genetics contribute to the prevalence of heart disease. Older age is a significant risk factor.

In states like Colorado with a higher median age, the population has more individuals at an increased risk for heart disease. Conversely, Utah's younger demographic may not face such immediate risks, leading to a lower overall death rate despite higher rates in younger groups.

This highlights the importance of age as a major factor in evaluating heart disease risk, emphasizing the need for health data to be analyzed with an understanding of demographic differences.
Exploring Age Group Analysis with Simpson's Paradox
Age group analysis is a way to investigate differences across various age segments in a population. This type of analysis helps in understanding nuances in data that might not be visible in overall statistics.

Simpson's Paradox is a phenomenon where trends seen in individual groups appear reversed when groups are combined. In the Utah vs. Colorado scenario, even though Utah has a higher death rate from heart disease in specific age groups, the younger overall population skews the total death rate lower.

The paradox illustrates how important it is to examine data carefully to understand underlying patterns and not just surface level trends. By breaking data into smaller groups, more accurate assessments can be made, ultimately leading to better-informed public health policies and interventions.

One App. One Place for Learning.

All the tools & learning materials you need for study success - in one app.

Get started for free

Most popular questions from this chapter

Basketball paradox The following list summarizes shooting percentage in the \(2001-2002\) season in the National Basketball Association by Brent Barry and Shaquille O'Neal. 2-point shots \(\bullet\) Brent Barry: \(58.8 \%(237 / 403)\) \(\bullet\) Shaquille O'Neal: \(58.0 \%(712 / 1228)\) 3-point shots \(\bullet\) Brent Barry: \(42.4 \%(164 / 387)\) \(\bullet\) Shaquille O'Neal: \(0 \%(0 / 1)\) Overall \(\bullet\) Brent Barry: \(50.8 \%(401 / 790)\) \(\bullet\) Shaquille O'Neal: \(57.9 \%(712 / 1229)\) a. Treating the type of shot as a control variable, whether a shot is made as the response variable, and the player as the explanatory variable, explain how these results illustrate Simpson's paradox. b. Explain how O'Neal could have the higher overall percentage, even though he made a lower percentage of each type of shot.

Chelation useless? Chelation is an alternative therapy for heart disease that uses repeated intravenous administration of a human-made amino acid in combination with oral vitamins and minerals. Practitioners believe it removes calcium deposits from buildup in arteries. However, the evidence for a positive effect is anecdotal or comes from nonrandomized, uncontrolled studies. A double-blind randomized clinical trial comparing chelation to placebo used a treadmill test in which the response was the length of time until a subject experienced ischemia (lack of blood flow and oxygen to the heart muscle). a. After 27 weeks of treatment, the sample mean time for the chelation group was 652 seconds. A \(95 \%\) confidence interval for the population mean for chelation minus the population mean for placebo was -53 to 36 seconds. Explain how to interpret the confidence interval. b. A significance test comparing the means had P-value = 0.69. Specify the hypotheses for this test, which was two-sided. c. The authors concluded from the test,"There is no evidence to support a beneficial effect of chelation therapy" (M. Knudtson et al., JAMA, vol. 287, p. 481 ,2002). Explain how this conclusion agrees with inference based on the values in the confidence interval.

Student survey \(\quad\) Refer to the FL Student Survey data file on the text CD. Use the number of times reading a newspaper as the response variable and gender as the explanatory variable. The observations are as follows: $$ \begin{array}{ll} \text { Females: } & 5,3,6,3,7,1,1,3,0,4,7,2,2,7,3,0,5,0,4,4, \\ & 5,14,3,1,2,1,7,2,5,3,7 \\ \text { Males: } & 0,3,7,4,3,2,1,12,1,6,2,2,7,7,5,3,14,3,7, \\ & 6,5,5,2,3,5,5,2,3,3 \end{array} $$ Using software, a. Construct and interpret a plot comparing responses by females and males. b. Construct and interpret a \(95 \%\) confidence interval comparing population means for females and males. c. Show all five steps of a significance test comparing the population means. d. State and check the assumptions for part b and part \(c\).

Reducing risk summaries and interpretations a. A New York Times health article (August 13,2009\()\) about a new study reported in the Journal of American Medical Association stated that, "patients with colorectal cancer who were regular aspirin users had a much better chance of surviving than nonusers, and were almost onethird less likely to die of the disease, while those who began using aspirin for the first time after the diagnosis cut their risk of dying by almost half." Which descriptive measure does "one-third" refer to? Interpret. b. An AP story (September 10,2003\()\) stated, "Brisk walking for just an hour or two weekly can help older women reduce their risk of breast cancer by 18 percent," according to an analysis of 74,171 women in the Women's Health Initiative study. Explain how to form a sample relative risk measure that equals \(0.82,\) for comparing those who briskly walk for an hour or two weekly to those who do not take such walks. Note: In this part and the next one, it may help you to use the result that Percent reduction in risk \(=(1-\) relative risk \() * 100 \%\) c. A Science Daily article (Nov. 17,2006 ) reported that taking low-dose aspirin daily reduces the risk of heart attack and stroke, as well as the risk of dying, among patients who previously have had a heart attack or stroke, according to analysis by Duke University Medical Center cardiologists. The researchers found that patients who took low-dose aspirin had a \(26 \%\) reduction in the risk of a nonfatal heart attack and a \(25 \%\) reduction in the risk of stroke compared with similar heart patients who did not take aspirin. State this result by defining and interpreting a relative risk for comparing those taking an aspirin a day to those who do not take an aspirin a day for the risk of nonfatal heart attacks. d. An AP story (February 9,2011 ) reported on a preliminary study presented at the International Stroke Conference in California stating that "daily diet soda drinkers (there were 116 in the study) had a 48 percent higher risk of stroke or heart attack than people who drank no soda of any kind ( 901 people, or \(35 \%\) of total participants). That's after taking into account rates of smoking, diabetes, waistline size, and other differences among the groups. No significant differences in risk were seen among people who drank a mix of diet and regular soda." Report the relative risk value for stroke or heart attack in this statement, and interpret.

Binge drinking The PACE project (pace.uhs.wisc.edu) at the University of Wisconsin in Madison deals with problems associated with high-risk drinking on college campuses. Based on random samples, the study states that the percentage of UW students who reported bingeing at least three times within the past two weeks was \(42.2 \%\) in \(1999(n=334)\) and \(21.2 \%\) in \(2009(n=843)\) a. Estimate the difference between the proportions in 1999 and \(2009,\) and interpret. b. Find the standard error for this difference. Interpret it. c. Construct and interpret a \(95 \%\) confidence interval to estimate the true change, explaining how your interpretation reflects whether the interval contains \(0 .\) d. State and check the assumptions for the confidence interval in part \(\mathrm{c}\) to be valid.

See all solutions

Recommended explanations on Math Textbooks

View all explanations

What do you think about this solution?

We value your feedback to improve our textbook solutions.

Study anywhere. Anytime. Across all devices.