/*! This file is auto-generated */ .wp-block-button__link{color:#fff;background-color:#32373c;border-radius:9999px;box-shadow:none;text-decoration:none;padding:calc(.667em + 2px) calc(1.333em + 2px);font-size:1.125em}.wp-block-file__button{background:#32373c;color:#fff;text-decoration:none} Problem 5 For each of the statistical stud... [FREE SOLUTION] | 91Ó°ÊÓ

91Ó°ÊÓ

For each of the statistical studies described, indicate whether the study is an observational study or an experiment. Give a brief explanation for your choice. A paper appearing in The Journal of Pain (March 2010 , 199-209) described a study to determine if meditation has an effect on sensitivity to pain. Study participants were assigned to one of three groups. One group meditated for 20 minutes; one group performed a distraction task (working math problems!) for 20 minutes; and one group practiced a relaxation technique for 20 minutes. Sensitivity to pain was measured both before and after the 20 -minute session.

Short Answer

Expert verified
The study described in The Journal of Pain is an experiment. This is because the researchers are assigning participants to different groups and manipulating variables to measure the effect of tasks on pain sensitivity.

Step by step solution

01

Identify the study design based on the given description

We have three groups of participants, who are assigned to perform different tasks. Since the researcher assigns the tasks to each group, this study is an experiment.
02

Explain the reasoning behind the classification

The main reason for classifying the study as an experiment is that the researchers are actively manipulating the variables by assigning the tasks to each group. If the researchers were only observing the existing behavior and the outcomes, without any intervention or manipulation, the study would be an observational study. However, in this case, the researchers are assigning different tasks and measuring the effect of these tasks on pain sensitivity, making it an experiment.
03

Conclusion

Based on the steps above, the study described in The Journal of Pain is an experiment. This is because the researchers are assigning participants to different groups and manipulating variables to measure the effect of tasks on pain sensitivity.

Unlock Step-by-Step Solutions & Ace Your Exams!

  • Full Textbook Solutions

    Get detailed explanations and key concepts

  • Unlimited Al creation

    Al flashcards, explanations, exams and more...

  • Ads-free access

    To over 500 millions flashcards

  • Money-back guarantee

    We refund you if you fail your exam.

Over 30 million students worldwide already upgrade their learning with 91Ó°ÊÓ!

Key Concepts

These are the key concepts you need to understand to accurately answer the question.

Observational Study
While learning about statistical studies, it's vital to understand what an observational study entails. Unlike an experiment, observational studies involve monitoring subjects without influencing their actions or the environment. Researchers simply observe and collect data related to the study's interest. For instance, a scientist might record eating habits of individuals to understand their dietary patterns without suggesting any changes to their diet.

In such studies, variables are not manipulated; they are naturally occurring. This method allows for the examination of real-world behaviors and outcomes but is limited because it can only suggest associations rather than causation. That's because without manipulating the variables, we cannot definitively determine if one factor directly affects another.
Experiment
Moving on to experiments, these are a type of study where researchers actively take the reins. In an experiment, the people conducting the study deliberately change one or more variables to observe the effect of this change on another variable. The key feature of an experiment, like the one mentioned in the journal, is the intentional assignment of interventions to the participants.

The aim is often to establish a cause-and-effect relationship by comparing outcomes between different groups that have been exposed to various conditions. For example, when researchers assigned meditation or other tasks to groups to gauge the effect on pain sensitivity, they were conducting an experiment. It's an active research method that goes beyond observing to interact with study subjects.
Variable Manipulation
What sets experiments apart from observational studies is variable manipulation. It involves changing one variable to determine if there's an effect on another, which we call the dependent variable. This type of direct intervention allows researchers to isolate cause and effect more precisely.

In the context of the study from The Journal of Pain, the independent variable manipulated by the researchers is the activity the participants engaged in, such as meditation or working on math problems. The dependent variable they measured was the participants' sensitivity to pain. This purposeful manipulation under controlled conditions is what enables scientists to draw conclusions about causality, not just correlation.
Sensitivity to Pain
Sensitivity to pain is a complex variable that can be influenced by a multitude of factors from physiological to psychological. When used as a dependent variable in a study, it requires careful measurement before and after the introduction of treatments or interventions. In the reported experiment, measuring pain sensitivity helped determine the effectiveness of various activities like meditation in altering the perception of pain.

Assessment techniques might include pressure pain thresholds, tolerance tests, or self-reported pain scales. Understanding how sensitivity to pain can be affected by different variables is crucial in fields such as medicine, psychology, and neuroscience. It also requires meticulous design to ensure accurate and meaningful results that can potentially lead to better pain management strategies.

One App. One Place for Learning.

All the tools & learning materials you need for study success - in one app.

Get started for free

Most popular questions from this chapter

1.31 In an experiment to assess the effect of wearing compression socks during a marathon, 20 runners in the 2013 Hartford Marathon were randomly assigned to two groups ("Compression and Clots in Athletes Who Travel," Lower Extremities Review, lermagazine.com/ler-archives/january -2016, retrieved July 2, 2017). Runners in one group wore a pair of compression socks during the marathon, while runners in the second group wore regular athletic socks. At the end of the marathon, blood samples were taken to measure variables related to preventing blood clots and speeding up recovery from exercise. a. Describe why it was important for the researchers to assign participants to one of the two groups rather than letting the participants choose which group they wanted to be in. b. The authors of the paper state that there is some evidence that suggests that wearing compression socks may result in a psychological advantage that might translate into performance gains. Suppose that instead of a response variable that was determined by a blood test, the response variable had been the time it took the runner to complete the marathon. Do you think it would be a good idea to have the runners be blind to the type of socks that they were given? Explain why or why not.

A survey of Arizona drivers is described in the article "Study Claims Safety Should Be Made Law" (Red Rock News, August 21,2015\()\). The following statement is from the article: According to the annual survey, which aims to gauge the opinions and concerns of the motoring public across the state regarding traffic safety, Arizona drivers want better traffic safety laws. The survey showed that nine in 10 Arizonans -91 percent \(-\) favor a statewide ban on texting while driving for all drivers, and about two-thirds -64 percent \(-\) favor a primary seat belt law. The article also describes how the data for this survey were collected. A survey was mailed to 2500 randomly selected AAA Arizona members (AAA Arizona is an automobile club that provides services to approximately 860,000 members in Arizona). The article did not indicate how many of the surveys were actually returned. The results of this survey were generalized to all Arizona drivers. Answer the following four questions for this observational study. (Hint: Reviewing Examples 1.4 and 1.5 might be helpful.) a. What is the population of interest? b. Was the sample selected in a reasonable way? c. Is the sample likely to be representative of the population of interest? d. Are there any obvious sources of bias?

A study described in Food Network Magazine (January 2012) concluded that people who push a shopping cart at a grocery store are less likely to purchase junk food than those who use a hand-held basket. a. Do you think this study was an observational study or an experiment? b. Is it reasonable to conclude that pushing a shopping cart causes people to be less likely to purchase junk food? Explain why or why not.

For each of the following, determine whether the statistical study described is an observational study or an experiment. Give a brief explanation of your choice. a. Can choosing the right music make wine taste better? This question was investigated by a researcher at a university in Edinburgh (www.decanter.com/wine-news /montes-music-makes-wine-reach-parts-it-otherwise -couldnt-reach-82325/, retrieved April 8,2017 ). Each of 250 volunteers was assigned at random to one of five rooms where they were asked to taste and rate a glass of wine. No music was playing in one of the rooms, and a different style of music was playing in each of the other four rooms. The researcher concludedFor each of the following, determine whether the statistical study described is an observational study or an experiment. Give a brief explanation of your choice. a. Can choosing the right music make wine taste better? This question was investigated by a researcher at a university in Edinburgh (www.decanter.com/wine-news /montes-music-makes-wine-reach-parts-it-otherwise -couldnt-reach-82325/, retrieved April 8,2017 ). Each of 250 volunteers was assigned at random to one of five rooms where they were asked to taste and rate a glass of wine. No music was playing in one of the rooms, and a different style of music was playing in each of the other four rooms. The researcher concluded that cabernet sauvignon is rated more highly when bold music is played than when no music is played. b. The article "Display of Health Risk Behaviors on MySpace by Adolescents" (Archives of Pediatrics and Adolescent Medicine [2009]: 27-34) described a study of 500 publically accessible MySpace web profiles posted by 18 -year- olds. The content of each profile was analyzed and the researchers concluded that those who indicated involvement in sports or a hobby were less likely to have references to risky behavior (such as sexual references or references to substance abuse or violence). c. USA TODAY (January 29,2003 ) reported that in a study of affluent Americans (defined as those with incomes of \$ 75,000\( or more per year) \)57 \%$ indicated that they would rather have more time than more money. d. The article "Acupuncture for Bad Backs: Even Sham Therapy Works" (Time, May 12,2009 ) summarized a study conducted by researchers at the Group Health Center for Health Studies in Seattle. In this study, 638 adults with back pain were randomly assigned to one of four groups. People in group 1 received the usual care for back pain. People in group 2 received acupuncture at a set of points tailored specifically for each individual. People in group 3 received acupuncture at a standard set of points typically used in the treatment of back pain. Those in group 4 received fake acupuncture- they were poked with a toothpick at the same set of points used for the people in group 3 . Two notable conclusions from the study were: (1) patients receiving real or fake acupuncture experienced a greater reduction in pain than those receiving usual care; and (2) there was no significant difference in pain reduction between those who received real acupuncture (groups 2 and 3 ) and those who received fake acupuncture toothpick pokes.

The article "Heartfelt Thanks to Fido" (San Luis Obispo Tribune, July 5,2003 ) summarized a study that appeared in the American Journal of Cardiology (March 15, 2003). In this study, researchers measured heart rate variability (a measure of the heart's ability to handle stress) in patients who had recovered from a heart attack. They found that heart rate variability was higher (which is good and means the heart can handle stress better) for those who owned a dog than for those who did not. a. Based on this study, is it reasonable to conclude that owning a dog causes higher heart rate variability? Explain. b. Is it reasonable to generalize the results of this study to all adult Americans? Explain why or why not.

See all solutions

Recommended explanations on Math Textbooks

View all explanations

What do you think about this solution?

We value your feedback to improve our textbook solutions.

Study anywhere. Anytime. Across all devices.