Chapter 20: Q45P (page 1078)
(A true story) The manager of an organic chemistry stockroom prepared unknowns for鈥淜etones and Aldehydes鈥 experiment by placing two drops of the liquid unknowns in test tubes and storing the test tubes for several days until they were needed. One of the unknowns was misidentified by every student. This unknown was taken from a bottle marked 鈥淗eptaldehyde.鈥 The stockroom manager took an IR spectrum of the liquid in the bottle and found a sharp carbonyl stretch around and small, sharp peaks around 2710 and . The students complained that their spectra showed no peaks at 2710 or , but a broad absorption centered over the region and a carbonyl peak around . They also maintained that their samples are soluble in dilute aqueous sodium hydroxide.
(a)Identify the compound in the stockroom manager鈥檚 bottle and the compound in the students鈥 test tubes.
(b)Explain the discrepancy between the stockroom manager鈥檚 spectrum and the students鈥 results.
(c)Suggest how this misunderstanding might be prevented in the future.
Short Answer
(a)

(b) The difference between the two samples is one is aldehyde and another is a carboxylic acid.
(c) The problem can be prevented by keeping in an inert atmosphere or preparing fresh unknown samples.




