Two capacitors with the same capacitance \(C\) and charge \(Q\) are placed next to
each other, as shown in Fig. 3.39. The two positive plates are then connected
by a wire. Will charge flow in the wire? Consider two possible reasonings:
(A) Before the plates are connected, the potential differences of the two
capacitors are the same (because \(Q\) and \(C\) are the same). So the potentials
of the two positive plates are equal. Therefore, no charge will flow in the
wire when the plates are connected.
(B) Number the plates 1 through 4 , from left to right. Before the plates are
connected, there is zero electric field in the region between the capacitors,
so plate 3 must be at the same potential as plate 2 . But plate 2 is at a
lower potential than plate \(1 .\) Therefore, plate 3 is at a lower potential
than plate 1 , so charge will flow in the wire when the plates are connected.
Which reasoning is correct, and what is wrong with the wrong reasoning?