/*! This file is auto-generated */ .wp-block-button__link{color:#fff;background-color:#32373c;border-radius:9999px;box-shadow:none;text-decoration:none;padding:calc(.667em + 2px) calc(1.333em + 2px);font-size:1.125em}.wp-block-file__button{background:#32373c;color:#fff;text-decoration:none} Problem 62 A biologist would like to determ... [FREE SOLUTION] | 91Ó°ÊÓ

91Ó°ÊÓ

A biologist would like to determine which of two brands of weed killer, X or \(Y\), is less likely to harm the plants in a garden at the university. Before spraying near the plants, the biologist decides to conduct an experiment using 24 individual plants. Which of the following two plans for randomly assigning the treatments should the biologist use? Why? Plan A: Choose the 12 healthiest-looking plants. Then flip a coin. If it lands heads, apply Brand X weed killer to these plants and Brand Y weed killer to the remaining 12 plants. If it lands tails, do the opposite. Plan B: Choose 12 of the 24 plants at random. Apply Brand X weed killer to those 12 plants and Brand \(Y\) weed killer to the remaining 12 plants.

Short Answer

Expert verified
Plan B is better due to unbiased randomization, ensuring balanced treatment groups.

Step by step solution

01

Identify Criteria for a Good Experimental Design

In order to decide the better plan for assigning treatments, we need to consider the criteria for a good experimental design: randomization and control. Randomization helps to eliminate bias by ensuring each plant has an equal chance of receiving any treatment. Control ensures that any differences in effects can be attributed to the treatments themselves rather than other variables.
02

Analyze Plan A

In Plan A, 12 healthiest plants are selected first and then a coin flip assigns the weed killers. This could introduce selection bias; the initial choice relies on plant health which is a strong variable that could confound results if either group ends up healthier by chance.
03

Analyze Plan B

In Plan B, 12 plants are selected at random for each treatment. This ensures that the selection process is unbiased and that all plants have an equal opportunity to receive either treatment. Randomly dividing the sample minimizes the influence of any pre-existing differences among the plants.
04

Determine the Better Plan

Plan B is preferred because its random assignment of treatments to plants ensures that each treatment group is likely balanced in terms of plant health, reducing bias and allowing for a clearer attribution of differences in outcomes to the treatments themselves rather than initial differences in plant conditions.

Unlock Step-by-Step Solutions & Ace Your Exams!

  • Full Textbook Solutions

    Get detailed explanations and key concepts

  • Unlimited Al creation

    Al flashcards, explanations, exams and more...

  • Ads-free access

    To over 500 millions flashcards

  • Money-back guarantee

    We refund you if you fail your exam.

Over 30 million students worldwide already upgrade their learning with 91Ó°ÊÓ!

Key Concepts

These are the key concepts you need to understand to accurately answer the question.

Randomization
Randomization is a crucial element in any experimental design, especially in scientific studies like the one involving weed killers. It involves randomly assigning subjects to different treatment groups to ensure that each subject has an equal chance of receiving any treatment. This process helps to eliminate selection bias, making sure that each group is comparable, and thus, any differences in the outcomes can be attributed to the treatments rather than pre-existing differences among the subjects.
In the biologist's experiment, Plan B exemplifies randomization effectively by choosing 12 plants at random for each treatment group. By doing so, it ensures that the assignment process is unbiased, and every plant, irrespective of its initial health status, could receive either Brand X or Brand Y weed killer.
  • Randomization balances both known and unknown factors across groups.
  • It provides a strong foundation to draw valid conclusions from the experiment.
Considering these advantages, randomization is a powerful tool to enhance the credibility and reliability of experimental findings.
Control in Experiments
Control in experiments refers to the practice of managing all other variables to ensure that the only factor affecting the outcome is the treatment itself. This concept is fundamental to experimental design as it helps establish a clear relationship between the treatment and the observed effects.
In the weed killer experiment, control can be seen as ensuring that both groups of plants experience the same environmental conditions such as sunlight, water, and soil type. This way, any observed differences in plant health can be confidently linked to the effect of the weed killers rather than external factors.
When an experiment has strong control, it becomes easier to assert that the results are due to the treatment. This clarity is pivotal for scientific inquiry.
  • Control helps to isolate the impact of the treatment.
  • It increases the confidence in attributing outcomes to the experimental intervention.
Implementing good control is crucial for producing valid and reliable results.
Bias Reduction in Experiments
Bias reduction is a key objective in experimental designs because bias can skew results, leading to misleading conclusions. There are various forms of bias, such as selection bias and measurement bias, that can affect the results of an experiment.
Plan A in the biologist's study introduces selection bias by picking the 12 healthiest plants, potentially confounding the results since these plants might inherently be more resilient. In contrast, Plan B reduces this bias by randomly selecting plants. This method helps ensure that each treatment group's baseline characteristics are similar, minimizing difference-related biases.
Bias reduction is essential for:
  • Enhancing the reliability of the study results.
  • Ensuring the findings are accurate and applicable to broader contexts.
By proactively designing experiments that account for and minimize bias, researchers can improve the trustworthiness of their conclusions. Focusing on eliminating as many sources of bias as possible is key to any robust experimental setup.

One App. One Place for Learning.

All the tools & learning materials you need for study success - in one app.

Get started for free

Most popular questions from this chapter

As men age, their testosterone levels gradually decrease. This may cause a reduction in lean body mass, an increase in fat, and other undesirable changes. Do testosterone supplements reverse some of these effects? A study in the Netherlands assigned 237 men aged 60 to 80 with low or low-normal testosterone levels to either a testosterone supplement or a placebo. The report in the Journal of the American Medical Association described the study as a "double-blind, randomized, placebo-controlled trial." Explain each of these terms to someone who knows nothing about statistics.

A lumber company wants to estimate the proportion of trees in a large forest that are ready to be cut down. They use an aerial map to divide the forest into 200 equal-sized rectangles. Then they choose a random sample of 20 rectangles and examine every tree that's in one of those rectangles. (a) What is the name for this kind of sampling method? (b) Give a possible reason why the lumber company chose this method.

\(A\) club has 30 student members and 10 faculty members. The students are $$ \begin{array}{lllll} \hline \text { Abel } & \text { Fisher } & \text { Huber } & \text { Miranda } & \text { Reinmann } \\ \text { Carson } & \text { Ghosh } & \text { Jimenez } & \text { Moskowitz } & \text { Santos } \\ \text { Chen } & \text { Griswold } & \text { Jones } & \text { Neyman } & \text { Shaw } \\ \text { David } & \text { Hein } & \text { Kim } & \text { 0'Brien } & \text { Thompson } \\ \text { Deming } & \text { Hernandez } & \text { Klotz } & \text { Pearl } & \text { Utts } \\ \text { Elashoff } & \text { Holland } & \text { Liu } & \text { Potter } & \text { Varga } \\ \hline \end{array} $$ $$ \text { The faculty members are } $$ $$ \begin{array}{lllll} \hline \text { Andrews } & \text { Fernandez } & \text { Kim } & \text { Moore } & \text { West } \\ \text { Besicovitch } & \text { Gupta } & \text { Lightman } & \text { Phillips } & \text { Yang } \\ \hline \end{array} $$ The club can send 4 students and 2 faculty members to a convention. It decides to choose those who will go by random selection. Describe a method for using Table \(\mathrm{D}\) to select a stratified random sample of 4 students and 2 faculty. Then use line 123 to select the sample.

What proportion of students at your school use Twitter? To find out, you survey a simple random sample of students from the school roster. (a) Will your sample result be exactly the same as the true population proportion? Explain. (b) Which would be more likely to get your sample result closer to the true population value: an SRS of 50 students or an SRS of 100 students? Explain.

Do abandoned children placed in foster homes do better than similar children placed in an institution? The Bucharest Early Intervention Project found that the answer is a clear "Yes." The subjects were 136 young children abandoned at birth and living in orphanages in Bucharest, Romania. Half of the children, chosen at random, were placed in foster homes. The other half remained in the orphanages. \({ }^{55}\) (Foster care was not easily available in Romania at the time and so was paid for by the study.) What conclusion can we draw from this study? Explain.

See all solutions

Recommended explanations on Math Textbooks

View all explanations

What do you think about this solution?

We value your feedback to improve our textbook solutions.

Study anywhere. Anytime. Across all devices.