/*! This file is auto-generated */ .wp-block-button__link{color:#fff;background-color:#32373c;border-radius:9999px;box-shadow:none;text-decoration:none;padding:calc(.667em + 2px) calc(1.333em + 2px);font-size:1.125em}.wp-block-file__button{background:#32373c;color:#fff;text-decoration:none} Problem 14 Prayer and Healing. To study the... [FREE SOLUTION] | 91Ó°ÊÓ

91Ó°ÊÓ

Prayer and Healing. To study the effect of prayer on healing, patients with health problems are randomly divided into two groups. In one group, intercessors pray for the health of the patients. In the other group, patients are not prayed for. Patients do not know that they are being prayed for, and the persons who are praying do not come in contact with the patients for whom they pray. Medical outcomes in the two groups of patients are compared. Finally, the medical treatment team is also blind to the prayer group status of individual patients. \(\frac{16}{}\) Is this experiment double-blind? What are the treatments? Is one of the treatments a placebo? Explain your answers.

Short Answer

Expert verified
Yes, the experiment is double-blind. Treatments are prayer and no prayer. No treatment is a placebo.

Step by step solution

01

Understanding Double-Blind

In a double-blind experiment, neither the participants (patients) nor the people conducting the experiment (such as the doctors and medical staff) know who belongs to the control group and who belongs to the experimental group. This is done to eliminate bias from both participants' and observers' sides.
02

Analyzing the Double-Blind Aspect

In this experiment, the patients do not know they are being prayed for, which satisfies one condition of a double-blind experiment. Additionally, the medical treatment team does not know the prayer group status. Therefore, this experiment is double-blind because both the subjects and the treating team are unaware of the group assignments.
03

Identifying the Treatments

In this study, there are two treatments being compared: prayer as a form of healing intervention (where the intercessors pray for the patients), and the lack of prayer, which serves as the control treatment. Thus, the two treatments are 'prayer' and 'no prayer'.
04

Understanding Placebo Treatments

A placebo treatment involves a situation where patients receive an inactive substance or treatment that looks identical to the actual treatment but does not contain the active ingredient under examination. It is used to isolate the effect of the treatment being studied. In this study, the 'no prayer' group serves as a comparison group but does not fit the traditional definition of a placebo.
05

Conclusion about Placebo

Although 'no prayer' acts as a control to compare the effects of prayer, it is not a placebo in the traditional medical sense because it lacks the aspect of deception involved in typical placebo treatments where patients believe they might be getting an active treatment.

Unlock Step-by-Step Solutions & Ace Your Exams!

  • Full Textbook Solutions

    Get detailed explanations and key concepts

  • Unlimited Al creation

    Al flashcards, explanations, exams and more...

  • Ads-free access

    To over 500 millions flashcards

  • Money-back guarantee

    We refund you if you fail your exam.

Over 30 million students worldwide already upgrade their learning with 91Ó°ÊÓ!

Key Concepts

These are the key concepts you need to understand to accurately answer the question.

Double-Blind Experiment
In a double-blind experiment, both the participants and the experimenters do not know who is receiving a particular treatment. This approach minimizes bias and increases the reliability of the experiment. In our study of prayer and healing, the setup ensures that neither the patients nor the medical treatment team is aware of which patients are being prayed for. The patients, not knowing about the prayer, cannot change their behavior in anticipation of healing. Similarly, medical staff, unaware of who is in the prayer group, provide unbiased evaluations of the patient's progress.
  • Participants are blind: Patients do not know if they are part of the prayer group or not.
  • Experimenters are blind: Medical staff is unaware of who receives prayers.
This method removes biases that could skew the experimental results, making it a robust experiment.
Control Group
A control group is essential in experimental design to establish a baseline effect. By comparing an experimental group receiving treatment to a control group that does not, researchers can discern the treatment’s true impact. In this study, the control group consists of patients who are not prayed for. Their medical outcomes are used as a benchmark against those who are. By keeping the control and experimental conditions consistent except for the prayer intervention, the researchers aim to highlight any true differences attributable to prayer itself.
  • Purpose: Serves as a benchmark for measuring treatment effects.
  • Composition: Patients receiving no prayer act as the control group.
Control groups are crucial for understanding what changes in the treatment group might genuinely result from the intervention.
Placebo Effect
The placebo effect occurs when patients experience real changes in their condition despite receiving an inactive treatment or substance. It plays a significant role in medical trials where distinguishing between actual and perceived changes is crucial. In this experiment, the group not receiving prayer is purely for comparison and does not constitute a placebo due to the absence of deception or an inactive agent resembling actual treatment. While a classic placebo involves pretending to medicate, here there's no such element, leading to a clear focus on whether prayer alone yields quantifiable health benefits without psychological influence.
  • No active treatment is disguised.
  • Participants are not deceived about receiving any fictitious treatment.
Therefore, while similar in purpose, this setup does not conform to the classic definition of a placebo effect.
Randomized Assignment
Randomized assignment ensures each participant in a study has an equal chance of being placed in either the treatment or control group. This process minimizes selection bias and attempts to balance confounding variables across both groups. In this prayer study, randomization means patients are divided into the two groups, prayer or no prayer, without consideration of any characteristics they may have. Essentially, it assures that the two groups are equivalent at the start of the experiment, allowing any differences observed to be more confidently attributed to the effect of the intervention rather than pre-existing differences.
  • Ensures initial equivalence of groups based on chance, not manipulation.
  • Makes findings more generalizable and reliable.
Randomization is key to achieving fair and unbiased results in experiments by creating comparable groups.

One App. One Place for Learning.

All the tools & learning materials you need for study success - in one app.

Get started for free

Most popular questions from this chapter

.Treating Sinus Infections. Sinus infections are common, and doctors commonly treat them with antibiotics. Another treatment is to spray a steroid solution into the nose. A well-designed clinical trial found that these treatments, alone or in combination, do not reduce the severity or the length of sinus infections. \(\frac{34}{4}\) The clinical trial was a completely randomized experiment that assigned 240 patients at random among four treatments, as follows: a. The report of this study in the Journal of the American Medical Association describes it as a "double-blind, randomized, placebo-controlled factorial trial." "Factorial" means that the treatments are formed from more than one factor. What are the factors? What do "double-blind" and "placebo-controlled" mean? b. If the random assignment of patients to treatments did a good job of eliminating bias, possible lurking variables such as smoking history, asthma, and hay fever should be similar in all four groups. After recording and comparing many such variables, the investigators said that "all showed no significant difference between groups." Explain to someone who knows no statistics what "no significant difference" means. Does it mean that the presence of all these variables was exactly the same in all four treatment groups?

Better Sleep? Is the number of times you awaken during the night affected by whet her you have a glass of wine before bed and whether you have a snack before you go to bed? Describe briefly the design of an experiment with two explanatory variables-whether or not you have a glass of wine and whether or not you have a snack before going to bed -to investigate this question. Be sure to specify what the response variable will be. Also tell how you will handle lurking variables such as amount of sleep the previous night.

Does exposure to aircraft noise increase the risk of hospitalization for cardiovascular disease in older people ( \(\geq 65\) years) residing near airports? Selecting a random sample of approximately 650,000 Medicare claims, it was found that about 75,000 people had zip codes near airports, and the remaining 575,000 did not. The proportions of hospital admissions related to cardiovascular disease were computed for those with zip codes near airports and those who did not have zip codes near airports. A larger proportion of admissions for cardiovascular disease was found for older people living in zip codes near airports. Which of the following statements is correct? a. Since this is an observational study, living in a zip code near an airport may or may not be causing the increase in the proportions of admissions for cardiovascular disease. b. Because of the large sample sizes from each group, we can claim that living in a zip code near an airport is causing the increase in the proportion of admissions for cardiovascular disease. c. Because this is an experiment, although not a randomized experiment, we can still conclude that living in a zip code near an airport is causing the increase in the proportions of admissions for cardiovascular disease.

Liquid Water Enhancers? Bottled water, flavored and plain, is expected to become the largest segment of the liquid refreshment market by the end of this decade, surpassing traditional carbonated soft drinks. 35 Kraft's MiO, a liquid water enhancer, comes in a variety of flavors, and a few drops added to water creates a zero-calorie flavored water drink. You wonder if those who drink flavored water like the taste of MiO as well as they like the taste of a competing flavored water product that comes ready to drink. a. Describe a matched pairs experiment to answer this question. Be sure to include proper blinding of your subjects. What is your response variable going to be? b. You have 20 people on hand who prefer to drink flavored water. Use the Simple Random Sample applet, software, or Table B at line 138 , to do the randomization that your design requires.

The Font Matters! In general, when trying to change your behavior, if the effort required is perceived as high, this will be an impediment to change, whether it is modifying your diet or your study habits. Researchers divided 40 students into two groups of 20 . The first group reads instructions for an exercise program printed in an easy-to-read font (Arial, 12 point), and the second group reads identical instructions in a difficult-to-read font (Brush, 12 point). Each subject estimates how many minutes the program will take and also uses a seven-point rating scale to report whether they are likely to include the exercise program as part of their daily routine ( 7 = very likely). The researchers hypothesized that those reading about the exercise program in the more difficult-toread font would estimate that the program would take longer and, they would be less likely to make the exercise program part of their regular routine. 3 Is this an experiment? Why or why not? What are the explanatory and response variables?

See all solutions

Recommended explanations on Math Textbooks

View all explanations

What do you think about this solution?

We value your feedback to improve our textbook solutions.

Study anywhere. Anytime. Across all devices.