/*! This file is auto-generated */ .wp-block-button__link{color:#fff;background-color:#32373c;border-radius:9999px;box-shadow:none;text-decoration:none;padding:calc(.667em + 2px) calc(1.333em + 2px);font-size:1.125em}.wp-block-file__button{background:#32373c;color:#fff;text-decoration:none} Problem 92 Infections Can Lower IQ A headli... [FREE SOLUTION] | 91Ó°ÊÓ

91Ó°ÊÓ

Infections Can Lower IQ A headline in June 2015 proclaims "Infections can lower IQ." 1 The headline is based on a study in which scientists gave an IQ test to Danish men at age \(19 .\) They also analyzed the hospital records of the men and found that \(35 \%\) of them had been in a hospital with an infection such as an STI or a urinary tract infection. The average IQ score was lower for the men who had an infection than for the men who hadn't. (a) What are the cases in this study? (b) What is the explanatory variable? Is it categorical or quantitative? (c) What is the response variable? Is it categorical or quantitative? (d) Does the headline imply causation? (e) Is the study an experiment or an observational study? (f) Is it appropriate to conclude causation in this case?

Short Answer

Expert verified
a) The cases in this study are the Danish men. b) The explanatory variable is whether the men have had an infection and it is categorical. c) The response variable is the IQ score and it is quantitative. d) The headline does imply causation. e) It's an observational study. f) It is improper to conclude causation based on this study.

Step by step solution

01

Identify the cases in the study

The cases in this study are the Danish men who were tested at the age of 19.
02

Identify the explanatory variable and its type

The explanatory variable is the men's hospitalization for an infection (like an STI or a urinary tract infection). This is a categorical variable indicating if the person has had an infection or not.
03

Identify the response variable and its type

The response variable is the IQ score of the Danish men. This is a quantitative variable as IQ scores can be measured on a numerical scale.
04

Analyze the headline for implied causation

The headline 'Infections can lower IQ.' does imply causation as it suggests that infections directly cause a lower IQ.
05

Determine the type of the study

The study is an observational study. The researchers did not manipulate any variables or randomly assign participants to different groups but instead, studied the outcome as it naturally occurred.
06

Discuss the appropriateness of determining causation

No, it's not appropriate to conclude causation in this case. Even though the study found a correlation between infection and lower IQ scores, this does not necessarily mean the infection caused the lower IQ. Other third variables might be influencing this correlation. The claim of causation especially from an observational study requires a very thorough examination and careful interpretation.

Unlock Step-by-Step Solutions & Ace Your Exams!

  • Full Textbook Solutions

    Get detailed explanations and key concepts

  • Unlimited Al creation

    Al flashcards, explanations, exams and more...

  • Ads-free access

    To over 500 millions flashcards

  • Money-back guarantee

    We refund you if you fail your exam.

Over 30 million students worldwide already upgrade their learning with 91Ó°ÊÓ!

Key Concepts

These are the key concepts you need to understand to accurately answer the question.

Explanatory Variable
When delving into the realm of research and statistics, the term explanatory variable often surfaces. This concept is pivotal as it represents the potential influence or cause in a study. For example, if researchers want to discern if studying habits impact test scores, the amount of time spent studying would be considered the explanatory variable.

In the context of the provided exercise, the explanatory variable is the hospitalization for an infection, such as an STI or a urinary tract infection. This variable is categorical, meaning it divides the cases into categories – in this scenario, those who have been hospitalized for an infection versus those who have not. It is essential to clearly define and understand the explanatory variable, for it frames the direction the study takes and guides the analytical interpretation.
Response Variable
Complementing the explanatory variable is the response variable, also known as the dependent variable. It is the outcome researchers are interested in dissecting or predicting. It typically answers the question 'What changes?' when the explanatory variable is altered. Imbuing clarity and preciseness during its designation is crucial for reliable and interpretable results.

In the exercise, the IQ score of the Danish men is identified as the response variable. This is because the IQ score is the outcome being measured after considering whether the individuals had an infection. IQ scores are quantitative variables, as they are expressed numerically, and hence, can be measured and meaningfully ordered or ranked.
Causation in Observational Studies
Understanding causation in observational studies can be like navigating a labyrinth due to the complexities and nuances involved. Causation implies that one event is the result of the occurrence of the other event; i.e., there is a cause and effect relationship. However, merely observing an association between two variables doesn't prove that one causes the other. Confounding factors may exist that contribute to or confuse the relationship.

Returning to our exercise example, while the headline implies that infections can lower IQ, implying a causal relationship, the format of an observational study makes that conclusion unreliable. Observational studies are inherently limited in their ability to prove causation because they don't control for all potential confounding variables, nor do they involve random assignment which is necessary to establish cause and effect. Therefore, even though an association was observed, declaring that infections cause a decrease in IQ could be misleading without further experimental evidence.
Quantitative and Categorical Variables
Distinguishing between quantitative and categorical variables is at the heart of statistical analysis, as they are the building blocks of data.

Quantitative Variables are numerical and measurable. They represent a measurable quantity and allow for mathematical operations – examples include height, weight, and, in our exercise, IQ score.

Categorical Variables, on the other hand, describe characteristics or qualities and are sorted into groups or categories. These variables are not necessarily numerical and often include demographic information like gender, race, or the presence of an infection as displayed in the exercise.

Identifying whether a variable is quantitative or categorical will dictate the type of statistical analysis that is suitable for interpreting the data and will ultimately influence the findings of a study.

One App. One Place for Learning.

All the tools & learning materials you need for study success - in one app.

Get started for free

Most popular questions from this chapter

In elementary school (grades 1 to 6 ), there is a strong association between a child's height and the child's reading ability. Taller children tend to be able to read at a higher level. However, there is a very significant confounding variable that is influencing both height and reading ability. What is it?

Next time you see an elderly man, check out his nose and ears! While most parts of the human body stop growing as we reach adulthood, studies show that noses and ears continue to grow larger throughout our lifetime. In one study \(^{14}\) examining noses, researchers report "Age significantly influenced all analyzed measurements:" including volume, surface area, height, and width of noses. The gender of the 859 participants in the study was also recorded, and the study reports that "male increments in nasal dimensions were larger than female ones." (a) How many variables are mentioned in this description? (b) How many of the variables are categorical? How many are quantitative? (c) If we create a dataset of the information with cases as rows and variables as columns, how many rows and how many columns would the dataset have?

Example 1.5 studied a variant of the gene \(A C T N 3\) which inhibits fast- twitch muscles and seems to be less prevalent in sprinters. A separate study \(^{9}\) indicated ethnic differences: Approximately \(20 \%\) of a sample of Caucasians, approximately \(25 \%\) of a sample of Asians, and approximately \(1 \%\) of a sample of Africans had the gene variant. What are the variables in this study? Classify each as categorical or quantitative.

"Antibiotics in infancy may cause obesity in adults," claims a recent headline. \(^{49}\) A study in mice randomly assigned infant mice to either be given antibiotics or not, and the mice given antibiotics were more likely to be obese as adults. A separate study in humans found that children who had been given antibiotics before they were a year old (for example, for an ear infection) were more likely to be obese as adults. (Researchers believe the effect may be due to changes in the gut microbiome.) Based on these studies, is the headline an appropriate conclusion to make: (a) For mice? (b) For humans?

To examine whether playing music in a store increases the amount customers spend, we randomly assign some stores to play music and some to stay silent and compare the average amount spent by customers.

See all solutions

Recommended explanations on Math Textbooks

View all explanations

What do you think about this solution?

We value your feedback to improve our textbook solutions.

Study anywhere. Anytime. Across all devices.