/*! This file is auto-generated */ .wp-block-button__link{color:#fff;background-color:#32373c;border-radius:9999px;box-shadow:none;text-decoration:none;padding:calc(.667em + 2px) calc(1.333em + 2px);font-size:1.125em}.wp-block-file__button{background:#32373c;color:#fff;text-decoration:none} Problem 65 An article in the San Luis Obisp... [FREE SOLUTION] | 91Ó°ÊÓ

91Ó°ÊÓ

An article in the San Luis Obispo Tribune (September 7,1999 ) described an experiment designed to investigate the effect of creatine supplements on the development of muscle fibers. The article states that the researchers "looked at 19 men, all about 25 years of age and similar in weight, lean body mass, and capacity to lift weights. Ten were given creatine \(-25\) grams a day for the first week. followed by 5 grams a day for the rest of the study. The rest were given a fake preparation. No one was told what he was getting. All the men worked out under the guidance of the same trainer. The response variable measured was gain in fat- free mass (in percent)." a. What extraneous variables are identified in the given statement, and what strategy did the researchers use to deal with them? b. Do you think it was important that the men participating in the experiment were not told whether they were receiving creatine or the placebo? Explain. c. This experiment was not conducted in a double-blind manner. Do you think it would have been a good idea to make this a double-blind experiment? Explain.

Short Answer

Expert verified
a. Extraneous variables include the subjects' age, weight, lean body mass, and weight-lifting capacity. Researchers controlled them by selecting similar subjects. b. Yes, it was important for subjects not to know if they were receiving creatine or the placebo to prevent the placebo effect. c. Yes, making this a double-blind experiment would have been a good idea to prevent experimenter bias and unintentional influence on the results.

Step by step solution

01

Identify Extraneous Variables

Extraneous variables are those unwanted influences that could affect the outcome of the experiment. From the information provided, several extraneous variables are identified including: age, weight, lean body mass, and weight-lifting capacity of the subjects. The researchers controlled these by choosing subjects who were all about the same age, similar in weight, lean body mass, and capacity.
02

Importance of Blind Testing

Yes, it was crucial that the men participating in the experiment were not informed about whether they were receiving creatine or the placebo. This is because of the placebo effect, where the belief of receiving treatment can induce an effect, as if a real treatment was received. This helps avoid biased measurements in the experiment.
03

Necessity of Double-Blind Experiment

Yes, a double-blind experiment would be beneficial. In a double-blind design, neither the participants nor the experimenters would know who is getting a particular treatment. This also prevents the experimenters from unintentionally biasing the results with their expectations or affecting the behavior of the subjects.

Unlock Step-by-Step Solutions & Ace Your Exams!

  • Full Textbook Solutions

    Get detailed explanations and key concepts

  • Unlimited Al creation

    Al flashcards, explanations, exams and more...

  • Ads-free access

    To over 500 millions flashcards

  • Money-back guarantee

    We refund you if you fail your exam.

Over 30 million students worldwide already upgrade their learning with 91Ó°ÊÓ!

Key Concepts

These are the key concepts you need to understand to accurately answer the question.

Extraneous Variables
Extraneous variables are factors that can potentially influence the results of an experiment without being of primary interest. In the experiment mentioned, the researchers wanted to study the effect of creatine on muscle fiber development. However, variables such as age, weight, lean body mass, and weight-lifting capacity could also affect the results.
To handle this, the researchers carefully selected participants who were similar in these characteristics. This approach helps to "control" or minimize the impact of these extraneous variables.
By ensuring uniformity in these characteristics, the researchers can be more confident that any observed effects are due to the creatine rather than other factors. This selection method helps make the results more reliable and attributes changes primarily to the independent variable being tested (creatine consumption in this case).
  • Age
  • Weight
  • Lean body mass
  • Weight-lifting capacity
Blind Experiment
In a blind experiment, participants are unaware of whether they are receiving the treatment or a placebo. This is crucial in eliminating biases that might be introduced if participants know what they are receiving.
For example, if the men knew they were taking creatine, they might consciously or subconsciously push themselves harder during workouts.
This could lead to results that reflect their efforts rather than the effect of the creatine itself. Blind experiments thus ensure that the impacts measured are due to the treatment alone rather than participant expectations.
By keeping participants in the dark, researchers can gather more accurate data on how effective a treatment really is, making the results of the study more trustworthy and scientifically valid.
Double-Blind Study
A double-blind study extends the benefits of a blind study by also keeping the experimenters or those administering the treatment unaware of who is receiving the creatine vs. the placebo. This mechanism serves two main purposes:
  • It prevents the experimenters from being biased in how they treat or observe participants.
  • It eliminates the risk of experimenters inadvertently giving cues or influencing participants.
In a double-blind setup, neither the participants nor the researchers have knowledge about who is receiving which type of treatment. This helps ensure that any psychological or subtle influences are completely removed, allowing the effect of the treatment to be isolated and clearly observed.
Such designs are particularly important in trials where subjective judgments are needed or where experimenter bias could significantly affect the results. By adopting a double-blind approach, studies seek to produce the most objective, valid, and repeatable results possible.
Placebo Effect
The placebo effect is a fascinating phenomenon where participants experience real changes in their health or condition simply because they believe they are receiving treatment. The belief itself can lead to tangible improvements, which can confound experimental results if not properly controlled for.
In medical experiments, participants might be given a "dummy" treatment that looks and feels like the real thing but has no therapeutic effect.
This helps researchers determine the treatment's real impact by comparing it against the psychological effects that arise from belief in the treatment.
The placebo effect underscores the power of the mind-body connection and highlights the importance of controlling for expectation-related biases in research.
In the creatine experiment, using a placebo allowed researchers to distinguish between real physiological changes due to creatine and those resulting from participants' belief that they were receiving the supplement. Such control mechanisms are vital for ensuring that the effects observed are due to the treatment itself, and not just participants' perceptions or beliefs.

One App. One Place for Learning.

All the tools & learning materials you need for study success - in one app.

Get started for free

Most popular questions from this chapter

During the previous calendar year, a county's small claims court processed 870 cases. Describe how a simple random sample of size \(n=50\) might be selected from the case files to obtain information regarding the average award in such cases.

Based on a survey conducted on the DietSmart.com web site, investigators concluded that women who regularly watched Oprah were only one-seventh as likely to crave fattening foods as those who watched other daytime talk shows (San Luis Obispo Tribune, October 14,2000 ). a. Is it reasonable to conclude that watching Oprah causes a decrease in cravings for fattening foods? Explain. b. Is it reasonable to generalize the results of this survey to all women in the United States? To all women who watch daytime talk shows? Explain why or why not.

As part of a curriculum review, the psychology department would like to select a simple random sample of 20 of last year's 140 graduates to obtain information on how graduates perceived the value of the curriculum. Describe two different methods that might be used to select the sample.

In national surveys, parents consistently point to school safety as an important concern. One source of violence in junior high schools is fighting ("Self-Reported Characterization of Seventh-Grade Student Fights" Journal of Adolescent Health \([1998]: 103-109)\). To construct a knowledge base about student fights, a school administrator wants to give two surveys to students after fights are broken up. One of the surveys is to be given to the participants, and the other is to be given to students who witnessed the fight. The type of information desired includes (1) the cause of the fight, (2) whether or not the fight was a continuation of a previous fight, (3) whether drugs or alcohol was a factor, (4) whether or not the fight was gang related, and (5) the role of bystanders. a. Write a set of questions that could be used in the two surveys. Each question should include a set of possible responses. For each question, indicate whether it would be used on both surveys or just on one of the two. b. How might the tendency toward positive selfpresentation affect the responses of the fighter to the survey questions you wrote for Part (a)? c. How might the tendency toward positive selfpresentation affect the responses of a bystander to the survey questions you wrote for Part (a)?

Explain why blinding is a reasonable strategy in many experiments.

See all solutions

Recommended explanations on Math Textbooks

View all explanations

What do you think about this solution?

We value your feedback to improve our textbook solutions.

Study anywhere. Anytime. Across all devices.