/*! This file is auto-generated */ .wp-block-button__link{color:#fff;background-color:#32373c;border-radius:9999px;box-shadow:none;text-decoration:none;padding:calc(.667em + 2px) calc(1.333em + 2px);font-size:1.125em}.wp-block-file__button{background:#32373c;color:#fff;text-decoration:none} Problem 55 Does ice cream prevent flu? Stat... [FREE SOLUTION] | 91Ó°ÊÓ

91Ó°ÊÓ

Does ice cream prevent flu? Statistical studies show that a negative correlation exists between the number of flu cases reported each week throughout the year and the amount of ice cream sold in that particular week. Based on these findings, should physicians prescribe ice cream to patients who have colds and flu or could this conclusion be based on erroneous data and statistically unjustified? a. Discuss at least one lurking variable that could affect these results. b. Explain how multiple causes could affect whether an individual catches flu.

Short Answer

Expert verified
Ice cream is not a cure for flu; seasonal factors affect both ice cream sales and flu cases. Other factors like immunity and exposure play crucial roles in flu prevention.

Step by step solution

01

Understanding Correlation vs. Causation

Statistical studies show a negative correlation between ice cream sales and flu cases, which means that as ice cream sales increase, flu cases appear to decrease and vice versa. However, correlation does not imply causation; this means that just because two variables appear related, one does not necessarily cause the other to happen.
02

Identifying Lurking Variables

A lurking variable is an outside factor that might affect both the variables in question. In this case, seasonality could be a lurking variable. During warmer months, people buy more ice cream and are generally more likely to be outdoors rather than in crowded indoor places where the flu virus spreads more readily. Thus, the decrease in flu cases might be due to seasonal behavior rather than ice cream consumption.
03

Recognizing Multiple Causes for Flu

There are multiple factors that affect whether an individual catches the flu, including their immune system strength, exposure to the virus, personal hygiene practices, and vaccination status. None of these factors are directly related to ice cream consumption, which suggests that the prevention of flu is more accurately attributed to these factors rather than the consumption of ice cream.

Unlock Step-by-Step Solutions & Ace Your Exams!

  • Full Textbook Solutions

    Get detailed explanations and key concepts

  • Unlimited Al creation

    Al flashcards, explanations, exams and more...

  • Ads-free access

    To over 500 millions flashcards

  • Money-back guarantee

    We refund you if you fail your exam.

Over 30 million students worldwide already upgrade their learning with 91Ó°ÊÓ!

Key Concepts

These are the key concepts you need to understand to accurately answer the question.

Lurking Variables
When analyzing the relationship between ice cream sales and flu cases, it is essential to be aware of lurking variables. These are hidden, unaccounted-for factors that may influence both variables in a study, giving the misleading impression of a direct connection. In the context of the ice cream and flu exercise, seasonality serves as a prime example of a lurking variable. When the weather is warm, people tend to indulge in more ice cream. At the same time, warm weather implies more time spent outdoors. Being outdoors reduces the chances of coming into contact with flu viruses, which are more likely to spread in enclosed, crowded environments.
  • For example, in summer, more social activities are hosted outside, limiting virus transmission.
  • Consequently, fewer flu cases are reported in these periods, irrespective of ice cream consumption.
Recognizing lurking variables helps clarify that the observed negative correlation between ice cream sales and flu cases is likely due to seasonal behavior rather than ice cream acting as a flu preventive.
Seasonality
Seasonality refers to patterns that repeat at regular intervals, often driven by changes in weather or climate throughout the year. In this exercise, seasonality is crucial to understanding the fluctuating patterns of ice cream sales and flu cases. During the summer, there's a natural increase in ice cream sales due to high temperatures. At the same time, there's a decrease in flu cases because the influenza virus doesn't spread as efficiently in warmer weather, when people spend more time outside.
  • In contrast, during winter, ice cream sales drop while flu cases rise.
  • People tend to stay indoors, which facilitates virus transmission due to prolonged proximity.
Understanding seasonality is vital for interpreting data correctly. Without recognizing seasonal influences, we might wrongly conclude that ice cream consumption directly impacts flu cases, when it is actually the time of year affecting both trends.
Flu Prevention
Preventing the flu involves understanding multiple causes that contribute to viral transmission, rather than relying on misconceptions like ice cream consumption. Common flu prevention strategies focus on minimizing exposure and boosting the immune system.
  • Vaccination remains one of the most effective methods. It helps your immune system recognize and combat the virus.
  • Maintaining good hygiene, such as handwashing and using sanitizers, reduces virus spread.
  • Eating a balanced diet also supports a strong immune system.
It is erroneous to believe that eating more or less ice cream will impact your chances of catching the flu. Instead, focusing on these scientifically supported strategies can effectively reduce flu cases. It's essential to remember that flu prevention is multi-faceted, involving personal, environmental, and healthcare factors.

One App. One Place for Learning.

All the tools & learning materials you need for study success - in one app.

Get started for free

Most popular questions from this chapter

Expected time for weight loss In \(2014,\) the statistical summary of a weight loss survey was created and published on www.statcrunch.com. a. In this study, it seemed that the desired weight loss (in pounds) was a good predictor of the expected time (in weeks) to achieve the desired weight loss. Do you expect \(r^{2}\) to be large or small? Why? b. For this data, \(r=0.607 .\) Interpret \(r^{2}\). c. Show the algebraic relationship between the correlation of 0.607 and the slope of the regression equation \(b=0.437,\) using the fact that the standard deviations are 20.005 for pounds and 14.393 for weeks. (Hint: Recall that \(\left.=r \frac{s_{y}}{s_{x}} .\right)\)

Sketch plots of lines Identify the values of the \(y\) -intercept \(a\) and the slope \(b\), and sketch the following regression lines, for values of \(x\) between 0 and \(10 .\) a. \(\hat{y}=7+0.5 x\) b. \(\hat{y}=7+x\) c. \(\hat{y}=7-x\) d. \(\hat{y}=7\)

NAEP scores In 2015 , eighth-grade math scores on the National Assessment of Educational Progress had a mean of 283.56 in Maryland compared to a mean of 284.37 in Connecticut (Source: http://nces.ed.gov/nationsreportcard/ naepdata/dataset.aspx). a. Identify the response variable and the explanatory variable. b. The means in Maryland were respectively \(274,284,285,\) 291 and 294 for people who reported the number of pages read in school and for homework, respectively as \(0-5,6-10,11-15,15-20\) and 20 or more. These means were 270,281,284,289 and 293 in Connecticut. Identify the third variable given here. Explain how it is possible for Maryland to have the higher mean for each class, yet for Connecticut to have the higher mean when the data are combined. (This is a case of Simpson's paradox for a quantitative response.)

Midterm-final correlation For students who take Statistics 101 at Lake Wobegon College in Minnesota, both the midterm and final exams have mean \(=75\) and standard deviation \(=10 .\) The professor explores using the midterm exam score to predict the final exam score. The regression equation relating \(y=\) final exam score to \(x=\) midterm exam score is \(\hat{y}=30+0.60 x\). a. Find the predicted final exam score for a student who has (i) midterm score \(=100,\) (ii) midterm score \(=50\). Note that in each case the predicted final exam score regresses toward the mean of \(75 .\) (This is a property of the regression equation that is the origin of its name, as Chapter 12 will explain.) b. Show that the correlation equals 0.60 and interpret it. (Hint: Use the relation between the slope and correlation.)

The previous problem discusses GDP, which is a commonly used measure of the overall economic activity of a nation. For this group of nations, the GDP data have a mean of 1909 and a standard deviation of 3136 (in billions of U.S. dollars). a. The five-number summary of GDP is minimum \(=204\), \(\mathrm{Q} 1=378,\) median \(=780, \mathrm{Q} 3=2015,\) and maximum \(=16,245 .\) Sketch a box plot. b. Based on these statistics and the graph in part a, describe the shape of the distribution of GDP values. c. The data set also contains per capita GDP, or the overall GDP divided by the nation's population size. Construct a scatterplot of per capita GDP and GDP and explain why no clear trend emerges. d. Your friend, Joe, argues that the correlation between the two variables must be 1 since they are both measuring the same thing. In reality, the actual correlation between per capita GDP and GDP is only \(0.32 .\) Identify the flaw in Joe's reasoning.

See all solutions

Recommended explanations on Math Textbooks

View all explanations

What do you think about this solution?

We value your feedback to improve our textbook solutions.

Study anywhere. Anytime. Across all devices.