/*! This file is auto-generated */ .wp-block-button__link{color:#fff;background-color:#32373c;border-radius:9999px;box-shadow:none;text-decoration:none;padding:calc(.667em + 2px) calc(1.333em + 2px);font-size:1.125em}.wp-block-file__button{background:#32373c;color:#fff;text-decoration:none} Problem 80 Multistage health survey \(\quad... [FREE SOLUTION] | 91Ó°ÊÓ

91Ó°ÊÓ

Multistage health survey \(\quad\) A researcher wants to study regional differences in dental care. He takes a multistage sample by dividing the United States into four regions, taking a simple random sample of ten schools in each region, randomly sampling three classrooms in each school, and interviewing all students in those classrooms about whether they've been to a dentist in the previous year. Identify each stage of this sampling design, indicating whether it involves stratification or clustering.

Short Answer

Expert verified
The sampling design involves stratification into regions, followed by clustering at the school and classroom levels.

Step by step solution

01

Understand the Overall Process

The exercise describes a multistage sampling design where the researcher uses different stages to collect data about dental care from students across the United States. Our goal is to identify and classify each sampling stage as stratification or clustering.
02

Identify and Classify the First Stage

The first stage involves dividing the United States into four regions. This step involves stratification because it entails dividing the population into distinct subgroups (regions) before sampling.
03

Identify and Classify the Second Stage

In this stage, a simple random sample of ten schools is taken in each region. This step involves clustering because each school represents a cluster, and all students in sampled schools (clusters) will be interviewed from selected classrooms.
04

Identify and Classify the Third Stage

The third stage involves randomly sampling three classrooms in each selected school. This stage is also clustering because each classroom is treated as a cluster, and all students within those classes are surveyed.
05

Identify the Final Step

In the final step, all students within the selected classrooms are interviewed. This is not a separate stage of sampling but rather the data collection phase within each cluster sampled in the previous step.

Unlock Step-by-Step Solutions & Ace Your Exams!

  • Full Textbook Solutions

    Get detailed explanations and key concepts

  • Unlimited Al creation

    Al flashcards, explanations, exams and more...

  • Ads-free access

    To over 500 millions flashcards

  • Money-back guarantee

    We refund you if you fail your exam.

Over 30 million students worldwide already upgrade their learning with 91Ó°ÊÓ!

Key Concepts

These are the key concepts you need to understand to accurately answer the question.

Stratification
In the first step of our multistage sampling design, we employ a technique called stratification. This method involves dividing a larger population, like a country, into smaller subgroups or 'strata.' In this exercise, the United States is divided into four regions. This doesn't just happen at random. It's a deliberate strategy aimed at getting a clearer and more accurate picture of the differences across these regions.

Why is stratification useful? It helps ensure that every distinct group is represented in the sample. This way, our survey results will reliably reflect the variations between regions. By using stratification, the researcher can understand how dental care varies across different parts of the country.

When you stratify:
  • You identify distinct groups (strata)
  • These groups are important for ensuring comprehensive coverage
  • Each group will be independently sampled to enhance the information gathered
This method is vital when regional representation is crucial to the study, as it helps analysts pinpoint differences that might affect the results.
Clustering
Clustering is another fundamental concept used in multistage sampling, applied in the subsequent steps of the sampling process. After the United States is divided into regions through stratification, clustering comes into play. First, the researcher randomly selects a small number of schools in each region. Here, each school represents a 'cluster.'

Why do researchers use clustering? It makes data collection manageable and cost-effective. Rather than sample individuals across vast distances, you gather data from naturally occurring groups. This not only saves time but also resources.

In this exercise:
  • Each selected school is a cluster
  • The researcher then samples classrooms within these clusters
  • Finally, all students in these chosen classrooms are interviewed
Clustering streamlines the survey process by focusing on groups rather than individuals. However, it's crucial that the clusters are chosen randomly to avoid bias and to ensure the outcomes are generalizable across the entire population.
Random Sampling
Random sampling is a technique that ensures unbiased representation by giving each member of the population an equal chance of being selected. In the multistage health survey, simplicity and randomness are crucial at several stages.

Throughout the process:
  • Schools within each region are selected randomly
  • Classrooms within schools are chosen randomly as well
This means that every school and classroom has an equal opportunity of being selected, provided they fall under the criteria set by the researcher in earlier steps. This randomness prevents any deliberate or unconscious bias which could skew the results.

Random sampling gives legitimacy to survey results as it makes them replicable and limits personal bias. Implementing this technique ensures that the sample mirrors the diversity and variability within the entire population.
Survey Design
Survey design is the backbone of any successful research project, guiding how data is collected, analyzed, and interpreted. In our multistage sampling example, the design is meticulously planned to capture important data about dental care across multiple regions.

What's in a good survey design? It involves deciding:
  • The target population and necessary subgroups
  • The sampling techniques like stratification and clustering
  • The measurement tools for collecting data
The purpose of such a structured design is to ensure that the study meets its objectives with accuracy and efficiency. Every survey has to be well thought out to minimize errors and enhance reliability.

In our scenario, the survey design dictates the flow from defining the population (U.S. regions), executing the sampling process (stratification and clustering), to finally collecting responses (interviewing students). Effective survey design means every detail is considered, from how questions are asked to how data is recorded, ensuring valid and actionable findings.

One App. One Place for Learning.

All the tools & learning materials you need for study success - in one app.

Get started for free

Most popular questions from this chapter

Baseball under a full moon Exercise 4.10 mentioned that the away team has won 13 consecutive games played between the Boston Brouhahas and Minnesota Meddlers during full moons. This is a statement based on retrospective observational data. a. Many databases are huge, including those containing sports statistics. If you had access to the database, do you think you could uncover more surprising trends? b. Would you be more convinced that the phase of the moon has predictive power if the away team were to win the next 13 games played under a full moon between Boston and Minnesota? c. The results of which type of observational study are generally more reliable, retrospective or prospective?

Reducing high blood pressure A pharmaceutical company has developed a new drug for treating high blood pressure. They would like to compare its effects to those of the most popular drug currently on the market. Two hundred volunteers with a history of high blood pressure and who are currently not on medication are recruited to participate in a study. a. Explain how the researchers could conduct a randomized experiment. Indicate the experimental units, the response and explanatory variables, and the treatments. b. Explain what would have to be done to make this study double-blind.

Smoking and heart attacks A Reuters story (April 2,2003) reported that "The number of heart attack victims fell by almost \(60 \%\) at one hospital six months after a smoke-free ordinance went into effect in the area (Helena, Montana), a study showed, reinforcing concerns about second-hand smoke." The number of hospital admissions for heart attack dropped from just under seven per month to four a month during the six months after the smoking ban. a. Did this story describe an experiment or an observational study? b. In the context of this study, describe how you could explain to someone who has never studied statistics that association does not imply causation. For instance, give a potential reason that could explain this association.

Pain reduction medication Consider an experiment being designed to study the effectiveness of an experimental pain reduction medication. The plan includes recruiting 100 individuals suffering from moderate to severe pain to participate. One half of the group will be assigned to take the actual experimental drug, and the other half will be assigned a placebo. The study will be blind in the sense that the individuals will not know which treatment they are receiving. At the end of the study, individuals will be asked to record using a standardized scale how much pain relief they experienced. Why is it important to use a placebo in such a study?

Capture-recapture Biologists and naturalists often use sampling to estimate sizes of populations, such as deer or fish, for which a census is impossible. Capture-recapture is one method for doing this. A biologist wants to count the deer population in a certain region. She captures 50 deer, tags each, and then releases them. Several weeks later, she captures 125 deer and finds that 12 of them were tagged. Let \(N=\) population size, \(M=\) size of first sample, \(n=\) size of second sample, \(R=\) number tagged in second sample. The table shows how results can be summarized. a. Identify the values of \(M, n,\) and \(R\) for the biologist's experiment. b. One way to estimate \(N\) lets the sample proportion of tagged deer equal the population proportion of tagged deer. Explain why this means that $$ \frac{R}{n}=\frac{M}{N} $$ and hence that the estimated population size is \(N=(M \times n) / R\) c. Estimate the number of deer in the deer population using the numbers given. d. The U.S. Census Bureau uses capture-recapture to make adjustments to the census by estimating the undercount. The capture phase is the census itself (persons are "tagged" by having returned their census form and being recorded as counted) and the recapture phase (the second sample) is the postenumerative survey (PES) conducted after the census. Label the table in terms of the census application.

See all solutions

Recommended explanations on Math Textbooks

View all explanations

What do you think about this solution?

We value your feedback to improve our textbook solutions.

Study anywhere. Anytime. Across all devices.