/*! This file is auto-generated */ .wp-block-button__link{color:#fff;background-color:#32373c;border-radius:9999px;box-shadow:none;text-decoration:none;padding:calc(.667em + 2px) calc(1.333em + 2px);font-size:1.125em}.wp-block-file__button{background:#32373c;color:#fff;text-decoration:none} Problem 36 Refer to the following story: Th... [FREE SOLUTION] | 91Ó°ÊÓ

91Ó°ÊÓ

Refer to the following story: The manufacturer of a new vitamin (vitamin \(X\) ) decides to sponsor a study to determine the vitamin's effectiveness in curing the common cold. Five hundred college students having a cold were recruited from colleges in the San Diego area and were paid to participate as subjects in this study. The subjects were each given two tablets of vitamin \(X\) a day. Based on information provided by the subjects themselves, 457 of the 500 subjects were cured of their colds within 3 days. (The average number of days a cold lasts is 4.87 days.) As a result of this study, the manufacturer launched an advertising campaign based on the claim that "vitamin \(X\) is more than \(90 \%\) effective in curing the common cold." Make some suggestions for improving the study.

Short Answer

Expert verified
Suggestions for improving the study involve expanding the sample size and demographic, implementing stringent data verification processes, incorporating a control group and placebo into the study, and repeating the experiment to consolidate the findings.

Step by step solution

01

Reassess the Population

The sample group chosen only consists of college students from San Diego, which is quite a narrow demographic. To make the study more comprehensive, it should be performed on a more diverse group of people; the subjects should vary in age, ethnic background, geographical location and health status. It is also worth noting that having a broader sample size could help mitigate any possible bias.
02

Verify the Method of Data Collection

Information on the treatment outcome was simply provided by the subjects themselves. This potentially leaves room for inaccurate reporting or even intentional deception. In future studies, a more stringent verification process should be implemented. Conducting proper medical examinations to confirm the treatment's effectiveness would be a way to validate the data.
03

Control Group & Placebo

There's no mention of any control group used in the study. A proper scientific study compares outcomes with and without the factor being studied. Therefore, a group should take the same regime without actually receiving the vitamin (placebo) to compare the results.
04

Repetition to Confirm Outcomes

For a study to conclusively claim an outcome, the experiment should be repeatable with the same findings. Therefore, the study should be performed more than once to confirm that vitamin X really does have this effect, and these outcomes weren't just due to chance.

Unlock Step-by-Step Solutions & Ace Your Exams!

  • Full Textbook Solutions

    Get detailed explanations and key concepts

  • Unlimited Al creation

    Al flashcards, explanations, exams and more...

  • Ads-free access

    To over 500 millions flashcards

  • Money-back guarantee

    We refund you if you fail your exam.

Over 30 million students worldwide already upgrade their learning with 91Ó°ÊÓ!

Key Concepts

These are the key concepts you need to understand to accurately answer the question.

Sample Diversity
In any scientific study, ensuring sample diversity is crucial, as it helps the results to be more generalizable to a larger population. In our vitamin study, the main sample group consisted solely of college students from San Diego. This limited demographic means that the results may not accurately reflect the effectiveness of the vitamin on different ages, ethnicities, or people with various health conditions.

A more diverse sample might include participants from different regions, age groups, health statuses, and ethnic backgrounds. For example:
  • Include participants of all ages, not just college students.
  • Incorporate people from various locations beyond San Diego.
  • Ensure a mix of different health statuses and pre-existing conditions.
By broadening the sample diversity, we can achieve a more comprehensive understanding of how vitamin X affects the general population.

This approach helps to mitigate bias and ensures that the conclusions drawn are more reliable and applicable to varied real-world settings.
Data Collection Methods
The accuracy of a study heavily relies on the data collection methods used. In the vitamin X study, data was self-reported by participants, leaving room for potential inaccuracies or intentional misreporting. To improve, rigorous data collection methods could be implemented.

Here are some strategies to better verify treatment outcomes:
  • Conduct regular medical examinations to verify the status of the cold independently from self-reports.
  • Implementing tracking symptoms through medical assessments rather than self-assessment.
  • Using health professionals to record and validate any improvement in the participants' condition.
By adopting these methods, the data's integrity is enhanced, making the results more credible.

Accurate data collection is vital for drawing valid conclusions about a treatment's effectiveness.
Control Groups
A fundamental component of a robust study design is the use of control groups. In this vitamin X study, no control group was utilized, which poses a significant flaw. Control groups are necessary to differentiate the effects of the treatment from natural recovery rates.

To implement a control group:
  • Select a group that receives no treatment or a placebo instead of vitamin X.
  • Ensure participants do not know if they are in the treatment or control group, maintaining the study’s blind nature.
  • Compare outcomes between the vitamin X group and the control group to assess real improvements.
By introducing control groups, the study can more accurately attribute changes in health to the vitamin rather than coincidence or natural resolution of the cold.

This plays a critical role in ensuring that claims about a treatment are substantiated by robust scientific evidence.
Placebo Effect
Understanding the placebo effect is vital when conducting experiments involving treatments. The placebo effect occurs when participants experience an improvement in symptoms simply because they believe they are receiving a treatment. In the vitamin X study, failing to account for the placebo effect could lead to overestimating the vitamin's effectiveness.

To control for the placebo effect, a placebo group should be included. This involves:
  • Providing identical-looking tablets that contain no active ingredients to the control group.
  • Maintaining the same treatment routine to ensure any changes are due to belief, not the actual vitamin.
  • Blinding both participants and researchers to treatment allocation until after the study to avoid biased results.
Accounting for the placebo effect allows researchers to discern the true efficacy of the vitamin X treatment, providing a clearer picture of its benefits or lack thereof.

Controlling for this phenomenon is a cornerstone of rigorous experimental design.
Reproducibility in Research
Reproducibility is the hallmark of good scientific research. It refers to the ability of an experiment to be repeated with consistent results, ensuring that findings are not anomalies. The vitamin X study needs to be reproducible for its results to be considered scientifically robust.

To guarantee reproducibility:
  • Conduct the study multiple times with varying populations, ensuring similar outcomes.
  • Publish detailed methodologies so other researchers can replicate the study.
  • Use standardized procedures across all iterations of the trial for consistent results.
Reproducing the study across different settings and conditions confirms the reliability of the conclusions. Without reproduction, we risk hinging decisions on potentially unique, unrepeatable outcomes.

By prioritizing reproducibility, researchers reinforce the credibility and validity of the findings in the broader scientific community.

One App. One Place for Learning.

All the tools & learning materials you need for study success - in one app.

Get started for free

Most popular questions from this chapter

Refer to the following story: The 1250 students at Eureka High School are having an election for Homecoming King. The candidates are Tomlinson (captain of the football team), Garcia (class president), and Marsalis (member of the marching band). At the football game a week before the election, a pre- election poll was taken of students as they entered the stadium gates. Of the students who attended the game, 203 planned to vote for Tomlinson, 42 planned to vote for Garcia, and 105 planned to vote for Marsalis. (a) Compare and contrast the population and the sampling frame for this survey. (b) Is the sampling error a result of sampling variability or of sample bias? Explain

(a) For the capture-recapture method to give a reasonable estimate of \(N\), what assumptions about the two samples must be true? (b) Give reasons why the assumptions in (a) may not hold true in many situations.

Refer to a study on the effectiveness of an HPV (human papilloma virus) vaccine conducted between October 1998 and November \(1999 .\) HPV is the most common sexually transmitted infection-more than 20 million Americans are infected with HPV-but most HPV infections are benign, and in most cases infected individuals are not even aware they are infected. (On the other hand, some HPV infections can lead to cervical cancer in women.) The researchers recruited 2392 women from 16 different centers across the United States to participate in the study through advertisements on college campuses and in the surrounding communities. To be eligible to participate in the study, the subjects had to meet the following criteria: (1) be a female between 16 and 23 years of age, (2) not be pregnant, (3) have no prior abnormal Pap smears, and (4) report to have had sexual relations with no more than five men. At each center, half of the participants were randomly selected to receive the HPV vaccine, and the other half received a placebo injection. After 17.4 months, the incidence of HPV infection was 3.8 per 100 woman-years at risk in the placebo group and 0 per 100 woman-years at risk in the vaccine group. In addition, all nine cases of HPV-related cervical precancerous growths occurred among the placebo recipients. (a) Describe the sample for the study. (b) Was the sample chosen using random sampling? Explain.

Imagine you have a very large coin jar full of nickels, dimes, and quarters. You would like to know how much money you have in the jar, but you don't want to go through the trouble of counting all the coins. You decide to estimate how many nickels, dimes, and quarters are in the jar using the capture- recapture method. After shaking the jar well, you draw a first sample of 150 coins and get 36 quarters, 45 nickels, and 69 dimes. Using a permanent ink marker you tag each of the 150 coins with a black dot and put the coins back in the jar, shake the jar really well to let the tagged coins mix well with the rest, and draw a second sample of 100 coins. The second sample has 28 quarters, 29 nickels, and 43 dimes. Of these, 4 quarters, 5 nickels, and 8 dimes have black dots. Estimate how much money is in the jar. (Hint: You will need a separate calculation for estimating the quarters, nickels, and dimes in the jar.)

Refer to a study conducted between 2008 and 2010 on the effectiveness of saw palmetto fruit extracts at treating lower urinary tract symptoms in men with prostate enlargement. (Saw palmetto is a widely used over-the-counter supplement for treating urinary tract symptoms.) In the study, 369 men aged 45 years or older were randomly divided into a group taking a daily placebo and a group taking saw palmetto. Participants were nonpaid volunteers recruited at 11 North American sites. All had moderately impaired urinary flow. Because the saw palmetto extract has a mild odor, the doses were administered using gelcaps to eliminate the odor. In an analysis of the 306 men who completed the 72 -week trial, both groups had similar small improvements in mean symptom scores, but saw palmetto conferred no benefit over placebo on symptom scores or on any secondary outcomes. (a) Describe the sample for the study. (b) Was the sample chosen using random sampling? Explain.

See all solutions

Recommended explanations on Math Textbooks

View all explanations

What do you think about this solution?

We value your feedback to improve our textbook solutions.

Study anywhere. Anytime. Across all devices.