/*! This file is auto-generated */ .wp-block-button__link{color:#fff;background-color:#32373c;border-radius:9999px;box-shadow:none;text-decoration:none;padding:calc(.667em + 2px) calc(1.333em + 2px);font-size:1.125em}.wp-block-file__button{background:#32373c;color:#fff;text-decoration:none} Problem 26 "More than half of Califomia's d... [FREE SOLUTION] | 91Ó°ÊÓ

91Ó°ÊÓ

"More than half of Califomia's doctors say they are so frustrated with managed care they will quit, retire early, or leave the state within three years." This conclusion from an article titled "Doctors Feeling Pessimistic, Study Finds" (San Luis Obispo Tribune, July 15,2001 ) was based on a mail survey conducted by the California Medical Association. Surveys were mailed to 19,000 Califomia doctors, and 2000 completed surveys were returned. Describe any concerns you have regarding the conclusion drawn.

Short Answer

Expert verified
The main concern regarding the conclusion drawn from the survey is the presence of a significant non-response bias. This bias emerges from the low response rate of doctors to the survey (~10.5%), suggesting that the doctors who are most frustrated might skew the results of the survey, providing a potentially misleading perception of the opinions of all California doctors.

Step by step solution

01

Understanding the Situation

Firstly, it is important to understand the situation and context as provided. The survey was conducted by the California Medical Association which targeted 19,000 California doctors, resulting in 2000 completed surveys. The study concludes that more than half of California's doctors say they are so frustrated with managed care they will quit, retire early or leave the state within three years.
02

Identification of Potential Sampling Bias

Next, comes the identification of potential biases. In this case, the concern is the potential for non-response bias. Of the 19,000 surveys sent out, only 2000 were returned. This is a response rate of approximately 10.5%. The low response rate is problematic, due to the possibility that the doctors who did respond may differ in important ways from those who didn't. For example, doctors who are more frustrated might be more likely to respond to the survey, skewed the results towards that sentiment.
03

Implication of Sampling Bias

Lastly, address the implication of the identified bias on the conclusion drawn from the survey. If only the doctors who are most dissatisfied responded, then the perception that 'More than half of California's doctors say they are so frustrated with managed care they will quit, retire early, or leave the state within three years' may be skewed and inaccurate. As a result, the survey's conclusion may only represent the views of a frustrated minority, not the entire population of California doctors.

Unlock Step-by-Step Solutions & Ace Your Exams!

  • Full Textbook Solutions

    Get detailed explanations and key concepts

  • Unlimited Al creation

    Al flashcards, explanations, exams and more...

  • Ads-free access

    To over 500 millions flashcards

  • Money-back guarantee

    We refund you if you fail your exam.

Over 30 million students worldwide already upgrade their learning with 91Ó°ÊÓ!

Key Concepts

These are the key concepts you need to understand to accurately answer the question.

Non-response Bias
In survey research, non-response bias occurs when the individuals who fail to participate in a survey differ significantly in their responses or characteristics from those who do participate. This bias can significantly affect the validity of survey results. In the case of the California Medical Association's survey, only 2000 of the 19,000 surveys sent out were completed, representing just over 10% of the target group.
This low response rate could mean that the sample of doctors who replied may not be representative of all California doctors. Those frustrated with managed care might have been more inclined to respond than those who are satisfied with their current conditions. This potential discrepancy leads to a distorted view of the overall sentiment among doctors about their careers in California. Considering such biases is essential in interpreting survey results accurately.
Survey Methodology
Survey methodology refers to the strategies and techniques used in conducting surveys, including how participants are selected and data is collected. Choosing the right survey methodology is crucial as it impacts the validity and reliability of the findings.
In the given exercise, the method involved mailing surveys to a large number of potential respondents. While mail surveys are cost-effective and can reach many participants, they often result in low response rates, which can deepen non-response bias.
  • Targeting the right sample size
  • Choosing effective survey distribution methods
  • Using follow-ups to increase response rates
These strategies are important for improving the accuracy and reliability of survey results. Additionally, understanding the limitations of a particular survey mode, like mail surveys, is important to anticipate potential challenges in data collection.
Response Rate
The response rate in a survey is the percentage of respondents who completed the survey out of those who were invited to participate. A high response rate is desirable because it generally indicates that the survey results more accurately represent the entire population. In this case, the response rate was about 10.5%, which is quite low.
Several factors can influence a survey's response rate:
  • The perceived relevance of the survey questions to the participant
  • The ease of completing the survey
  • The incentives offered to participate
Efforts to increase the response rate can include sending reminders, simplifying the survey process, and providing incentives. A higher response rate minimizes the potential for non-response bias and increases confidence in the survey’s findings.
Statistical Conclusion Validity
Statistical conclusion validity refers to the extent to which we can be confident in the inferences about the relationship between the variables studied. To achieve this, the survey must be rigorously designed and executed with a robust analysis of the collected data.
An issue in maintaining statistical conclusion validity is a biased sample, as seen in the initial exercise. If the surveyed group does not reflect the true characteristics of the entire population, conclusions drawn from the survey can be misleading. For example, if mainly frustrated doctors responded, this would not accurately reflect the opinions of all doctors.
Ensuring high statistical conclusion validity involves addressing potential biases, employing proper statistical techniques, and ensuring a representative sample. By doing so, we can make more accurate and trustworthy inferences based on survey data.

One App. One Place for Learning.

All the tools & learning materials you need for study success - in one app.

Get started for free

Most popular questions from this chapter

For each of the situations described, state whether the sampling procedure is simple random sampling, stratified random sampling, cluster sampling, systematic sampling, or convenience sampling. a. All freshmen at a university are enrolled in 1 of 30 sections of a seminar course. To select a sample of freshmen at this university, a researcher selects 4 sections of the seminar course at random from the 30 sections and all students in the 4 selected sections are included in the sample. b. To obtain a sample of students, faculty, and staff at a university, a researcher randomly selects 50 faculty members from a list of faculty, 100 students from a list of students, and 30 staff members from a list of staff. c. A university researcher obtains a sample of students at his university by using the 85 students enrolled in his Psychology 101 class. d. To obtain a sample of the seniors at a particular high school, a researcher writes the name of each senior on a slip of paper, places the slips in a box and mixes them, and then selects 10 slips. The students whose names are on the selected slips of paper are included in the sample. e, To obtain a sample of those attending a basketball game, a researcher selects the 24 th person through the door. Then, every 50 th person after that is also included in the sample.

Based on a survey of 4113 U.S. adults, researchers at Stanford University concluded that Internet use leads to increased social isolation. The survey was conducted by an Internet-based polling company that selected its samples from a pool of 35,000 potential respondents, all of whom had been given free Internet access and WebTV hardware in exchange for agreeing to regularly participate in surveys conducted by the polling company. Two criticisms of this study were expressed in an article that appeared in the San Luis Obispo Tribune (February 28,2000 ). The first criticism was that increased social isolation was measured by asking respondents if they were talking less to family and friends on the phone. The second criticism was that the sample was selected only from a group that was induced to participate by the offer of free Internet service, yet the results were generalized to all U.S. adults. For each criticism, indicate what type of bias is being described and why it might make you question the conclusion drawn by the researchers.

The paper "Prospective Randomized Trial of Low Saturated Fat, Low Cholesterol Diet During the First Three Years of Life" (Circulation [1996]: \(1386-1393\) ) describes an experiment in which " 1062 infants were randomized to either the intervention or control group at 7 months of age. The families of the 540 intervention group children were counseled to reduce the child's intake of saturated fat and cholesterol but to ensure adequate energy intake. The control children consumed an unrestricted diet." a. The researchers concluded that the blood cholesterol level was lower for children in the intervention group. Is it reasonable to conclude that the parental counseling and subsequent reduction in dietary fat and cholesterol are the cause of the reduction in blood cholesterol level? Explain why or why not. b. Is it reasonable to generalize the results of this experiment to all children? Explain.

Researchers at the Hospital for Sick Children in Toronto compared babies born to mothers with diabetes to babies born to mothers without diabetes ("Conditioning and Hyperanalgesia in Newborns Exposed to Repeated Heel Lances," Journal of the American Medical Association \([2002]: 857-861\) ). Babies born to mothers with diabetes have their heels pricked numerous times during the first 36 hours of life in order to obtain blood samples to monitor blood sugar level. The researchers noted that the babies born to diabetic mothers were more likely to grimace or cry when having blood drawn than the babies born to mothers without diabetes. This led the researchers to conclude that babies who experience pain early in life become highly sensitive to pain. Comment on the appropriateness of this conclusion.

A novel alternative medical treatment for heart at- tacks seeds the damaged heart muscle with cells from the patient's thigh muscle ("Doctors Mend Damaged Hearts with Cells from Muscles," San Luis Obispo Tribune, November 18,2002 ). Doctor Dib from the Arizona Heart Institute evaluated the approach on 16 patients with severe heart failure. The article states that "ordinarily, the heart pushes out more than half its blood with each beat. Dib's patients had such severe heart failure that their hearts pumped just 23 percent. After bypass surgery and cell injections, this improved to 36 percent, although it was impossible to say how much, if any, of the new strength resulted from the extra cells." a. Explain why it is not reasonable to generalize to the population of all heart attack victims based on the data from these 16 patients. b. Explain why it is not possible to say whether any of the observed improvement was due to the cell injections, based on the results of this study. c. Describe a design for an experiment that would allow researchers to determine whether bypass surgery plus cell injections was more effective than bypass surgery alone.

See all solutions

Recommended explanations on Math Textbooks

View all explanations

What do you think about this solution?

We value your feedback to improve our textbook solutions.

Study anywhere. Anytime. Across all devices.