/*! This file is auto-generated */ .wp-block-button__link{color:#fff;background-color:#32373c;border-radius:9999px;box-shadow:none;text-decoration:none;padding:calc(.667em + 2px) calc(1.333em + 2px);font-size:1.125em}.wp-block-file__button{background:#32373c;color:#fff;text-decoration:none} Problem 15 An election resulted in Candidat... [FREE SOLUTION] | 91Ó°ÊÓ

91Ó°ÊÓ

An election resulted in Candidate A winning, with Candidate B coming in a close second, and candidate \(\mathrm{C}\) being a distant third. If in a head- to-head comparison a majority of people prefer \(\mathrm{B}\) to \(\mathrm{A}\) or \(\mathrm{C}\), which is the primary fairness criterion violated in this election?

Short Answer

Expert verified
The Condorcet criterion is violated.

Step by step solution

01

Understand the Scenario

In the given election, Candidate A is the declared winner. Candidate B is the runner-up, and Candidate C is the third place. However, more people prefer Candidate B over the others in direct comparisons.
02

Know the Fairness Criteria

There are several fairness or voting criteria, such as the Condorcet criterion, Majority criterion, Independence of irrelevant alternatives, etc. We need to identify which is potentially violated when such a preference discrepancy exists.
03

Define the Condorcet Criterion

The Condorcet criterion states that a candidate who would win a head-to-head competition against each of the other candidates should be the winner. A candidate meeting this criterion is called the Condorcet winner.
04

Apply the Condorcet Criterion

In this case, Candidate B is preferred over Candidates A and C by a majority in individual match-ups. Thus, Candidate B is the Condorcet winner.
05

Identify the Violation

Since Candidate B, the Condorcet winner, is not elected as the overall winner, the election violates the Condorcet criterion.

Unlock Step-by-Step Solutions & Ace Your Exams!

  • Full Textbook Solutions

    Get detailed explanations and key concepts

  • Unlimited Al creation

    Al flashcards, explanations, exams and more...

  • Ads-free access

    To over 500 millions flashcards

  • Money-back guarantee

    We refund you if you fail your exam.

Over 30 million students worldwide already upgrade their learning with 91Ó°ÊÓ!

Key Concepts

These are the key concepts you need to understand to accurately answer the question.

Voting Fairness
In the context of elections, voting fairness is all about ensuring that the outcome reflects the true preferences of the electorate. This involves selecting a winner who genuinely represents the majority's choice when candidate comparisons are made. However, an election can sometimes result in the selection of a candidate who may not be the most preferred when compared head-to-head with others. This raises questions about fairness and whether the election method used has honored the principles of fair representation.
Consider a situation where a candidate, let’s call them Candidate B, is preferred by the majority over others like A and C when they are examined individually. If the final election result overlooks Candidate B in favor of others, it suggests a potential fairness issue, such as non-compliance with the Condorcet criterion. Fair voting systems aim to avoid such inconsistencies to maintain electoral integrity.
Candidate Preference
Candidate preference is the individual voter's ranking or choice of candidates, often reflecting who they wish to see elected into office. Preferences can be complex, involving not just a simple first-choice pick but a ranked ordering where voters express their direct comparisons between candidates.
In an ideal election, the winner aligns with the preferences of the majority in these one-on-one comparisons. For instance, if Candidate B is preferred head-to-head against both Candidates A and C, then intuitively, B should be the optimal choice according to the preferences expressed by the electorate. However, capturing these preferences accurately can be challenging depending on the election methods and systems in use.
Understanding and respecting candidate preferences are crucial for deriving outcomes that best reflect the collective will of the voters.
Election Methods
Election methods are the procedures and rules used to determine the winner of an election based on the votes cast by the electorate. These methods include various systems like plurality, runoff, approval voting, and the Condorcet method, each having its strengths and challenges.
The Condorcet method, named after the French mathematician and philosopher, involves pairwise comparisons to evaluate which candidate wins head-to-head against others. The candidate who can beat each other candidate in these comparisons is deemed the Condorcet winner and is viewed as the most favorable choice across the electorate.
Despite its theoretical appeal in reflecting voters' preferences, not all election systems incorporate the Condorcet criterion. For example, the traditional plurality system can elect a candidate who isn't the Condorcet winner, leading to outcomes that may not always satisfy principles of fairness and representative accuracy. Understanding different election methods helps in choosing systems that appropriately address the electorate's preferences.

One App. One Place for Learning.

All the tools & learning materials you need for study success - in one app.

Get started for free

Most popular questions from this chapter

An election resulted in Candidate A winning, with Candidate B coming in a close second, and candidate \(\mathrm{C}\) being a distant third. If for some reason the election had to be held again and \(\mathrm{C}\) decided to drop out of the election, which caused \(\mathrm{B}\) to become the winner, which is the primary fairness criterion violated in this election?

Instant Runoff Voting and Approval voting have supporters advocating that they be adopted in the United States and elsewhere to decide elections. Research comparisons between the two methods describing the advantages and disadvantages of each in practice. Summarize the comparisons, and form your own opinion about whether either method should be adopted.

Sequential Pairwise voting is a method not commonly used for political elections, but sometimes used for shopping and games of pool. In this method, the choices are assigned an order of comparison, called an agenda. The first two choices are compared. The winner is then compared to the next choice on the agenda, and this continues until all choices have been compared against the winner of the previous comparison. a. Using the preference schedule below, apply Sequential Pairwise voting to determine the winner using the agenda: A. B. C. D $$ \begin{array}{|c|c|c|c|} \hline \text { Number of voters } & \mathbf{1 0} & \mathbf{1 5} & \mathbf{1 2} \\\ \hline \text { 1st choice } & \mathrm{C} & \mathrm{A} & \mathrm{B} \\ \hline \text { 2nd choice } & \mathrm{A} & \mathrm{B} & \mathrm{D} \\ \hline \text { 3rd choice } & \mathrm{B} & \mathrm{D} & \mathrm{C} \\ \hline \text { 4th choice } & \mathrm{D} & \mathrm{C} & \mathrm{A} \\ \hline \end{array} $$ b. Show that Sequential Pairwise voting can violate the Pareto criterion. c. Show that Sequential Pairwise voting can violate the Majority criterion.

The Pareto criterion is another fairness criterion that states: If every voter prefers choice \(A\) to choice \(B\), then \(B\) should not be the winner. Explain why plurality, instant runoff, Borda count, and Copeland's method all satisfy the Pareto condition.

Copeland's Method is designed to identify a Condorcet Candidate if there is one, and is considered a Condorcet Method. There are many Condorcet Methods, which vary primarily in how they deal with ties, which are very common when a Condorcet winner does not exist. Copeland's method does not have a tie- breaking procedure built-in. Research the Schulze method, another Condorcet method that is used by the Wikimedia foundation that runs Wikipedia, and give some examples of how it works.

See all solutions

Recommended explanations on Math Textbooks

View all explanations

What do you think about this solution?

We value your feedback to improve our textbook solutions.

Study anywhere. Anytime. Across all devices.