Chapter 5: Problem 7
Let \(\mathbf{a}_{j}\) be a nonzero column vector of an \(m \times n\) matrix \(A .\) Is it possible for \(\mathbf{a}_{j}\) to be in \(N\left(A^{T}\right) ? \mathrm{Ex}\) plain.
Short Answer
Expert verified
No, it is not possible for a nonzero column vector, 饾憥饾憲, of matrix A to be in the null space of A岬 (N(A岬)). The contradiction arises when we find that A饾憥饾憲 = 饾憥饾憲 and A岬饾憥饾憲 = 0, which is impossible for a nonzero vector 饾憥饾憲.
Step by step solution
01
Understand the Null Space
The null space of a matrix M (denoted as N(M)) is the set of all vectors that when multiplied by the matrix result in the zero vector. Mathematically, if 饾懃 鈭 N(M), then M饾懃 = 0.
02
Relation between A and A岬
The transpose of a matrix, A岬, is obtained by flipping the matrix over its diagonal, resulting in the rows becoming columns and vice versa. If A is of size m 脳 n, then A岬 will be of size n 脳 m. The transpose operation doesn't affect the null space directly, but the operations in the original matrix A reveal a relationship between A and A岬.
03
Matrix multiplication of A and A岬
Let's consider the multiplication of A by one of its column vectors, 饾憥饾憲. The product of this multiplication is A饾憥饾憲. Since 饾憥饾憲 is the j-th column vector of A, A饾憥饾憲 results in a linear combination of the columns of A, where only the j-th column has a nonzero coefficient (which is 1). Hence, A饾憥饾憲 = 饾憥饾憲.
04
Analyze the possibility of 饾憥饾憲 being in N(A岬)
To check if 饾憥饾憲 could belong to the null space of A岬, we need to consider the result of the multiplication A岬饾憥饾憲. If 饾憥饾憲 鈭 N(A岬), then A岬饾憥饾憲 = 0. Now, let's recall the result of step 3, where we found that A饾憥饾憲 = 饾憥饾憲.
05
Evaluate the contradiction
We had found that A饾憥饾憲 = 饾憥饾憲 and now we are testing A岬饾憥饾憲 = 0. To clarify this contradiction, let's multiply 饾憥饾憲 on the left by A岬, so A岬A饾憥饾憲 = A岬0. From step 3, A饾憥饾憲 = 饾憥饾憲, so A岬饾憥饾憲 = 0. But we previously assumed that 饾憥饾憲 is a nonzero column vector of A, which leads to a contradiction since A岬饾憥饾憲 cannot be equal to 0.
06
Conclusion
Based on the analysis and the contradiction found in step 5, it is not possible for a nonzero column vector, 饾憥饾憲, of matrix A to be in the null space of A岬 (N(A岬)).
Unlock Step-by-Step Solutions & Ace Your Exams!
-
Full Textbook Solutions
Get detailed explanations and key concepts
-
Unlimited Al creation
Al flashcards, explanations, exams and more...
-
Ads-free access
To over 500 millions flashcards
-
Money-back guarantee
We refund you if you fail your exam.
Over 30 million students worldwide already upgrade their learning with 91影视!
Key Concepts
These are the key concepts you need to understand to accurately answer the question.
Transpose of a Matrix
A matrix's transpose is a fundamental concept in linear algebra. When transposing a matrix, you are essentially flipping it over its diagonal. This means its rows become columns and columns become rows. For example, if you have a matrix \( A \) that is \( m \times n \), then its transpose, denoted as \( A^{T} \), will be \( n \times m \). Understanding how to find and use the transpose can be very helpful in solving systems of equations and determining properties like symmetry.
Transposing a matrix doesn't affect the null space directly since it primarily involves rearranging the elements. However, understanding the structure of both \( A \) and \( A^{T} \) is crucial when exploring other concepts like matrix multiplication and null spaces, where relationships between these two forms are often analyzed. Keep this in mind as we delve deeper into related exercises. Using the transpose effectively requires familiarity with these transformations and how it compares to its original matrix.
Transposing a matrix doesn't affect the null space directly since it primarily involves rearranging the elements. However, understanding the structure of both \( A \) and \( A^{T} \) is crucial when exploring other concepts like matrix multiplication and null spaces, where relationships between these two forms are often analyzed. Keep this in mind as we delve deeper into related exercises. Using the transpose effectively requires familiarity with these transformations and how it compares to its original matrix.
Matrix Multiplication
Matrix multiplication is an operation that takes two matrices and produces another matrix. For matrices \( A \) (of size \( m \times n \)) and \( B \) (of size \( n \times p \)), the result is a new matrix \( C \) (of size \( m \times p \)). The basic operation involves summing the products of the rows of \( A \) and the columns of \( B \).
Understanding the rules of matrix multiplication is key, particularly when dealing with systems that require multiplying matrices by vectors, like in this exercise. When a column vector \( \mathbf{a}_j \) from matrix \( A \) is multiplied by matrix \( A \), it results in a linear combination of \( A \)'s columns. This linear combination highlights the important interaction between the rows and columns of matrices, fundamental when solving many algebraic problems.
Understanding the rules of matrix multiplication is key, particularly when dealing with systems that require multiplying matrices by vectors, like in this exercise. When a column vector \( \mathbf{a}_j \) from matrix \( A \) is multiplied by matrix \( A \), it results in a linear combination of \( A \)'s columns. This linear combination highlights the important interaction between the rows and columns of matrices, fundamental when solving many algebraic problems.
- Matrix multiplication is not commutative, meaning \( AB eq BA \). The order matters.
- It is associative: \( (AB)C = A(BC) \).
- It distributes over addition: \( A(B + C) = AB + AC \).
Linear Combination
The concept of a linear combination is central in linear algebra. It involves creating a new vector by multiplying existing vectors by scalars and then summing the results. This notion is crucial in understanding how vectors relate within vector spaces.
In the context of the exercise, multiplying \( A \) by its column vector \( \mathbf{a}_j \) results in a linear combination of \( A \)'s columns. The multiplication process allows each column to be a scaled version, contributing toward constructing the result. Therefore, \( A\mathbf{a}_j \) equals \( \mathbf{a}_j \) itself, as it emerges as a simple linear combination where most scaling factors are zero except for the \( j^{th} \) position which is one.
In the context of the exercise, multiplying \( A \) by its column vector \( \mathbf{a}_j \) results in a linear combination of \( A \)'s columns. The multiplication process allows each column to be a scaled version, contributing toward constructing the result. Therefore, \( A\mathbf{a}_j \) equals \( \mathbf{a}_j \) itself, as it emerges as a simple linear combination where most scaling factors are zero except for the \( j^{th} \) position which is one.
- A linear combination helps in determining the span of vector sets.
- It's crucial in solving equations where variables can be expressed in terms of known vectors.
- Identifying linear combinations is foundational for working with subspaces and bases.
Contradiction in Linear Algebra
A contradiction in linear algebra, like other areas of mathematics, signifies that something is logically inconsistent with other established facts or assumptions. When working through proofs or exercises, sometimes methods lead to conflicts that suggest an error in the assumed idea or given statements.
In this exercise, a contradiction arises when considering \( \mathbf{a}_j \) in \( N(A^T) \). Since \( A\mathbf{a}_j = \mathbf{a}_j \) is known, this conclusion directly conflicts with the statement \( A^Ta_j = 0 \). This relationship is absurd under the premises set by the properties of matrix multiplication and null spaces, creating a contradiction revealing the impossibility of \( a_j \) being in \( N(A^T) \).
In this exercise, a contradiction arises when considering \( \mathbf{a}_j \) in \( N(A^T) \). Since \( A\mathbf{a}_j = \mathbf{a}_j \) is known, this conclusion directly conflicts with the statement \( A^Ta_j = 0 \). This relationship is absurd under the premises set by the properties of matrix multiplication and null spaces, creating a contradiction revealing the impossibility of \( a_j \) being in \( N(A^T) \).
- Contradictions often help prove the non-existence or falseness of assumptions.
- They are useful in validating proofs by showing assumed propositions must be wrong.
- Recognizing contradictions helps refine mathematical arguments and methods.