/*! This file is auto-generated */ .wp-block-button__link{color:#fff;background-color:#32373c;border-radius:9999px;box-shadow:none;text-decoration:none;padding:calc(.667em + 2px) calc(1.333em + 2px);font-size:1.125em}.wp-block-file__button{background:#32373c;color:#fff;text-decoration:none} Problem 56 The paper titled "Music for Pain... [FREE SOLUTION] | 91Ó°ÊÓ

91Ó°ÊÓ

The paper titled "Music for Pain Relief" (The Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, April \(19 .\) 2006) concluded, based on a review of 51 studies of the effect of music on pain intensity, that "Listening to music reduces pain intensity levels .... However, the magnitude of these positive effects is small, the clinical relevance of music for pain relief in clinical practice is unclear." Are the authors of this paper claiming that the pain reduction attributable to listening to music is not statistically significant, not practically significant, or neither statistically nor practically significant? Explain.

Short Answer

Expert verified
The authors of the paper are suggesting that the pain reduction attributable to listening to music may not be practically significant, not that it is not statistically significant.

Step by step solution

01

Understand Statistical Significance

Statistical significance refers to the unlikelihood that the observed relation (in relation) between variables in a sample occurred by chance. If a result is statistically significant, it means the likelihood of it occurring by mere chance is very low.
02

Understand Practical Significance

Practical significance, on the other hand, refers to the importance or relevance of a research finding in real-world settings. A finding may be statistically significant (not due to chance) but not practically significant (not impactful or meaningful on a larger scale).
03

Analyze Authors' Claim

Applying these definitions to the authors' claim in the text, it can be inferred that they are arguing about the practical significance rather than statistical significance. They acknowledge that listening to music does affect pain intensity (hence it might be statistically significant), but they also express doubts about the 'magnitude of these positive effects' and their 'clinical relevance in practice', implying that they question its practical significance.

Unlock Step-by-Step Solutions & Ace Your Exams!

  • Full Textbook Solutions

    Get detailed explanations and key concepts

  • Unlimited Al creation

    Al flashcards, explanations, exams and more...

  • Ads-free access

    To over 500 millions flashcards

  • Money-back guarantee

    We refund you if you fail your exam.

Over 30 million students worldwide already upgrade their learning with 91Ó°ÊÓ!

Key Concepts

These are the key concepts you need to understand to accurately answer the question.

Statistical Significance
Statistical significance is a term thrown around quite often in research studies, but what exactly does it mean? Think of it like this: when scientists claim that something is statistically significant, they are confident that the outcome of their study did not happen by mere coincidence. It's like flipping a coin; if you get heads five times in a row, you might think it's a fluke. But if it lands on heads 50 times in a row, you'd be quite sure something is causing this skewed result – it's statistically significant.

To determine this, researchers use a specific threshold called the 'p-value'. If the p-value is lower than the chosen cutoff (usually 0.05), they reject the hypothesis that the results are due to random chance. This is what we're talking about when we refer to a result as being statistically significant. It's a bit like a seal of approval for the data saying, 'Yes, there is definitely something here worth looking at.'
Practical Significance
Practical significance takes us beyond numbers into the realm of real-world impact. Even if a result is statistically significant, we have to ask ourselves 'So what?' If the effect of an intervention or treatment is so small that it makes no difference in everyday life, can we truly say it matters? This is where the concept of practical significance comes in. It lets us consider not just whether an effect exists, but also whether it's large enough to care about.

For instance, let's say a new type of pencil claims to improve test scores. The study shows a statistically significant increase in scores, but the average improvement is less than 1%. In a classroom setting, such a trivial increase might not be practically significant. Educators and students would unlikely notice the change. Practical significance challenges us to look at the size and importance of an effect, encouraging a holistic approach to interpreting research findings.
Research Study Analysis
Research study analysis is the meticulous process of dissecting a study to understand and evaluate its components. This often involves examining the study's design, methodology, data collection, statistical analysis, and conclusions. It's like being a detective, looking closely at the evidence, and deciding whether it's solid or if there might be flaws that call the findings into question.

While reviewing research, we might look at sample size (is it large enough to generalize the results?), methodology (was the study designed well?), data analysis (were the proper statistical tests used?), and other critical aspects. By thoroughly analyzing research studies, we ensure that the conclusions we're drawing are founded on robust and reliable evidence.
Pain Intensity Reduction
Pain intensity reduction is a critical focus in clinical research, as it's a measure of how effectively a treatment alleviates pain. But here's the catch: even if a treatment can statistically significantly reduce pain intensity, the question of practical significance remains. How much does the pain need to reduce for a patient to feel better in their day-to-day activities?

It's not just about lower numbers on a pain scale; it's about improving quality of life. Patients and doctors alike are more interested in treatments that provide a noticeable change in comfort and ability to function. This is why, when reading research on treatments like music for pain relief, we scrutinize not only if they work but also if the level of pain reduction is meaningful to those receiving the treatment.

One App. One Place for Learning.

All the tools & learning materials you need for study success - in one app.

Get started for free

Most popular questions from this chapter

Do state laws that allow private citizens to carry concealed weapons result in a reduced crime rate? The author of a study carried out by the Brookings Institu-tion is reported as saying, "The strongest thing I could say is that I don't see any strong evidence that they are reducing crime" (San Luis Obispo Tribune, January \(23 .\) 2003). a. Is this conclusion consistent with testing \(H_{0}:\) concealed weapons laws reduce crime versus \(H_{a}:\) concealed weapons laws do not reduce crime or with testing \(H_{0}:\) concealed weapons laws do not reduce crime versus \(H_{a}:\) concealed weapons laws reduce crime Explain. b. Does the stated conclusion indicate that the null hypothesis was rejected or not rejected? Explain.

A television manufacturer claims that (at least) \(90 \%\) of its TV sets will need no service during the first 3 years of operation. A consumer agency wishes to check this claim, so it obtains a random sample of \(n=100\) purchasers and asks each whether the set purchased needed repair during the first 3 years after purchase. Let \(\hat{p}\) be the sample proportion of responses indicating no repair (so that no repair is identified with a success). Let \(p\) denote the actual proportion of successes for all sets made by this manufacturer. The agency does not want to claim false advertising unless sample evidence strongly suggests that \(p<.9\). The appropriate hypotheses are then \(H_{0}: p=.9\) versus \(H_{a}: p<.9\). a. In the context of this problem, describe Type I and Type II errors, and discuss the possible consequences of each. b. Would you recommend a test procedure that uses \(\alpha=.10\) or one that uses \(\alpha=.01 ?\) Explain.

Assuming a random sample from a large population, for which of the following null hypotheses and sample sizes \(n\) is the large-sample \(z\) test appropriate: a. \(H_{0}: p=.2, n=25\) b. \(H_{0}: p=.6, n=210\) c. \(H_{0}: p=.9, n=100\) d. \(H_{0}: p=.05, n=75\)

The report "2007 Electronic Monitoring \& Surveillance Survey: Many Companies Monitoring. \(\begin{aligned}&\text { Recording. } & \text { Videotaping-and } & \text { Firing-Employees" }\end{aligned}\) (American Management Association, 2007) summarized the results of a survey of 304 U.S. businesses. Of these companies, 201 indicated that they monitor \(\mathrm{em}-\) ployees' web site visits. For purposes of this exercise, assume that it is reasonable to regard this sample as representative of businesses in the United States. a. Is there sufficient evidence to conclude that more than \(60 \%\) of U.S. businesses monitor employees' web site visits? Test the appropriate hypotheses using a significance level of \(.01\). b. Is there sufficient evidence to conclude that a majority of U.S. businesses monitor employees' web site visits? Test the appropriate hypotheses using a significance level of \(.01\).

An article titled "Teen Boys Forget Whatever It Was" appeared in the Australian newspaper The Mercury (April 21, 1997). It described a study of academic performance and attention span and reported that the mean time to distraction for teenage boys working on an independent task was 4 minutes. Although the sample size was not given in the article, suppose that this mean was based on a random sample of 50 teenage Australian boys and that the sample standard deviation was \(1.4\) minutes. Is there convincing evidence that the average attention span for teenage boys is less than 5 minutes? Test the relevant hypotheses using \(\alpha=.01\).

See all solutions

Recommended explanations on Math Textbooks

View all explanations

What do you think about this solution?

We value your feedback to improve our textbook solutions.

Study anywhere. Anytime. Across all devices.