Chapter 2: Problem 33
Suppose \(A B=A C\) and \(A\) is a non invertible \(n \times n\) matrix. Does it follow that \(B=C ?\) Explain why or why not.
Short Answer
Expert verified
No, it does not follow. A non-invertible matrix implies the equation \( A(B - C) = 0 \) has non-unique solutions for \( B \) and \( C \).
Step by step solution
01
- Understanding the Given
It is given that if matrix A is non-invertible and of size \( n \times n \) (i.e., square matrix), and if \( A B = A C \), we need to determine whether it follows that \( B = C \).
02
- Define Non-Invertible Matrix
A matrix \( A \) is non-invertible (singular) if and only if its determinant is zero (\( \text{det}(A) = 0 \)). This means there is no matrix \( A^{-1} \) that satisfies \( AA^{-1} = I \), where \( I \) is the identity matrix.
03
- Analyze the Equation
Given \( A B = A C \), subtract \( A C \) from both sides to yield \( A B - A C = 0 \). Factoring out \( A \) from the left-hand side, we get \( A (B - C) = 0 \).
04
- Solve for \( B - C \)
For a non-invertible matrix \( A \), the equation \( A (B - C) = 0 \) does not guarantee \( B - C = 0 \) because \( A \) does not have a unique inverse to multiply both sides of the equation and isolate \( B - C \). Therefore, \( B - C \) could be any matrix that lies within the null space of \( A \).
05
- Conclusion
Since \( B - C \) can be any matrix in the null space of \( A \) and not necessarily the zero matrix, it does not follow that \( B = C \). There can be multiple pairs \((B, C)\) satisfying \( AB = AC \) with \( B eq C \).
Unlock Step-by-Step Solutions & Ace Your Exams!
-
Full Textbook Solutions
Get detailed explanations and key concepts
-
Unlimited Al creation
Al flashcards, explanations, exams and more...
-
Ads-free access
To over 500 millions flashcards
-
Money-back guarantee
We refund you if you fail your exam.
Over 30 million students worldwide already upgrade their learning with 91Ó°ÊÓ!
Key Concepts
These are the key concepts you need to understand to accurately answer the question.
Matrix Multiplication
Matrix multiplication is a fundamental operation in linear algebra. It involves the combination of two matrices to produce a new matrix. Given two matrices, say A and B, to multiply them, you perform the dot product of rows from the first matrix with columns of the second matrix.
For example, if A is of size \(n \times m\) and B is of size \(m \times p\), the resultant matrix C will be of size \(n \times p\). The element in the ith row and jth column of the resulting matrix C is computed as: \[ C_{ij} = \text{sum}(A_{ik} \times B_{kj}) \text{ for } k = 1 \text{ to } m \]
It is important to note that matrix multiplication is not commutative, meaning \( A \times B eq B \times A \). This property is essential to understanding many matrix operations and the behavior of systems of linear equations.
For example, if A is of size \(n \times m\) and B is of size \(m \times p\), the resultant matrix C will be of size \(n \times p\). The element in the ith row and jth column of the resulting matrix C is computed as: \[ C_{ij} = \text{sum}(A_{ik} \times B_{kj}) \text{ for } k = 1 \text{ to } m \]
It is important to note that matrix multiplication is not commutative, meaning \( A \times B eq B \times A \). This property is essential to understanding many matrix operations and the behavior of systems of linear equations.
Determinant
The determinant is a special number that can be calculated from a square matrix. The determinant of a matrix A is typically denoted as \( \text{det}(A) \). It provides important properties of the matrix, such as whether the matrix is invertible.
For a matrix to be invertible, its determinant must be non-zero. Conversely, if the determinant is zero, the matrix is known as **non-invertible** or **singular**. This means there is no matrix B such that \(AB = I\), where I is the identity matrix.
The determinant can also be used to find out if a set of linear equations has a unique solution. For an \(n \times n\) matrix, the determinant is computed by a process that involves recursive expansion along rows or columns, often called cofactor expansion.
In the context of our problem, matrix A being non-invertible (\( \text{det}(A) = 0 \)) plays a crucial role in determining why \(B = C\) does not necessarily follow from \(AB = AC\).
For a matrix to be invertible, its determinant must be non-zero. Conversely, if the determinant is zero, the matrix is known as **non-invertible** or **singular**. This means there is no matrix B such that \(AB = I\), where I is the identity matrix.
The determinant can also be used to find out if a set of linear equations has a unique solution. For an \(n \times n\) matrix, the determinant is computed by a process that involves recursive expansion along rows or columns, often called cofactor expansion.
In the context of our problem, matrix A being non-invertible (\( \text{det}(A) = 0 \)) plays a crucial role in determining why \(B = C\) does not necessarily follow from \(AB = AC\).
Null Space
The null space (or kernel) of a matrix A, denoted as \( \text{null}(A) \), is the set of all vectors x for which \(Ax = 0\). In simpler terms, it consists of all solutions to the equation where A times a vector equals the zero vector. A matrix's null space gives us insight into its behavior and properties.
For a matrix to be non-invertible, its null space must contain more than just the zero vector. This means there exists a non-zero vector x such that \(Ax = 0\).
In our particular problem, when we encounter \(A(B - C) = 0\), the term \(B - C\) lies in the null space of A. Since A is non-invertible, the null space is not trivial and \(B - C\) could be any non-zero vector in that space. This explains why \(B\) does not have to equal \(C\), because as long as \(B - C\) is in the null space of A, the original equation \(AB = AC\) holds true.
Understanding the null space is essential in many applications of linear algebra, particularly in solving linear systems and analyzing linear transformations.
For a matrix to be non-invertible, its null space must contain more than just the zero vector. This means there exists a non-zero vector x such that \(Ax = 0\).
In our particular problem, when we encounter \(A(B - C) = 0\), the term \(B - C\) lies in the null space of A. Since A is non-invertible, the null space is not trivial and \(B - C\) could be any non-zero vector in that space. This explains why \(B\) does not have to equal \(C\), because as long as \(B - C\) is in the null space of A, the original equation \(AB = AC\) holds true.
Understanding the null space is essential in many applications of linear algebra, particularly in solving linear systems and analyzing linear transformations.