Chapter 1: Problem 16
To maximize her time in Nomo, Hannah must spend a minimum of two days in each of the other 5 cities she visits, for a total of 10 days outside Nomo. Hence, the most time she can spend in Nomo is four days. This eliminates (C). Now, the other 5 cities could all be in countries Y and Z, which eliminates (E). On the other hand, up to 3 cities could be in country X (and the remaining cities in countries Y and Z), which eliminates (A). If it happens that three of the five cities besides Nomo are located in country Z, Hannah will spend more than four days in that country, eliminating choice (D). This leaves choice (B) as the answer. Let鈥檚 check that Hannah can indeed visit four cities in country Y: She visits Nomo in country X for four days. Then if she visits 4 cities in country Y for eight days and 1 city in country Z for two days, she fulfills all the conditions for her trip. So indeed statement (B) must be true. Note the unusual and subtle wording of this question: it asks which one of 5 possibilities must be true. To say that a possibility must be true is to claim that under some circumstances (but not necessarily all) the object of that possibility can be true. For example, to say 鈥渋t must be true that John can run a four minute mile鈥 is to say that 鈥淛ohn ran this particular mile in four minutes can be true.鈥 The key point is that the statement may be true but doesn鈥檛 have to be. The possibility must exist, but it need not be realized in every instance. So, in choice (B), the statement 鈥淗annah can visit four cities in Y鈥 must be true because there is a valid scenario in which she does visit four such cities鈥攅ven though there are other scenarios as well
Short Answer
Step by step solution
Key Concepts
These are the key concepts you need to understand to accurately answer the question.