/*! This file is auto-generated */ .wp-block-button__link{color:#fff;background-color:#32373c;border-radius:9999px;box-shadow:none;text-decoration:none;padding:calc(.667em + 2px) calc(1.333em + 2px);font-size:1.125em}.wp-block-file__button{background:#32373c;color:#fff;text-decoration:none} Problem 18 Some policy makers have claimed ... [FREE SOLUTION] | 91Ó°ÊÓ

91Ó°ÊÓ

Some policy makers have claimed that the U.S. government should purchase illegal drugs, such as cocaine, to increase the price that drug users face and therefore reduce their consumption. Does this idea have any merit? Illustrate this logic in a simple supply and demand framework. How does the elasticity of demand for illegal drugs relate to the efficacy of this policy? Are you more or less willing to favor this policy if you are told demand is inelastic?

Short Answer

Expert verified
The policy could be effective if demand is elastic, but less so if demand is inelastic, as drug consumption may not decrease significantly with price increases in the latter case.

Step by step solution

01

Understanding the Policy Proposal

The proposition suggests that the government should buy illegal drugs to reduce supply in the market. By doing so, it causes the supply curve to shift leftward, thereby increasing the price that consumers have to pay.
02

Illustrating the Supply and Demand Framework

In the supply and demand model, assume an initial equilibrium where the demand curve (D) intersects the supply curve (S). If the government buys drugs, the supply in the market decreases, causing the supply curve to shift left from S to S'. This leads to a new, higher equilibrium price at which the quantity supplied equals the new quantity demanded.
03

Analyzing the Impact of Price Change

An increase in price generally decreases the quantity demanded according to the law of demand. Depending on how much the price increases and how the market participants react, consumption of drugs can decrease, aligning with the policy's primary goal.
04

Role of Demand Elasticity

Elasticity of demand measures how sensitive the quantity demanded is to a price change. If the demand is elastic, a small price increase results in a large decrease in quantity demanded. Conversely, if demand is inelastic, even a large price increase might not significantly decrease consumption.
05

Addressing Inelastic Demand

If the demand for drugs is inelastic, significant price increases have little effect on consumption levels. Therefore, the policy may be less effective if demand is inelastic. With a small percentage reduction in consumption due to price change, resources used in buying drugs might yield minimal reductions in drug use.

Unlock Step-by-Step Solutions & Ace Your Exams!

  • Full Textbook Solutions

    Get detailed explanations and key concepts

  • Unlimited Al creation

    Al flashcards, explanations, exams and more...

  • Ads-free access

    To over 500 millions flashcards

  • Money-back guarantee

    We refund you if you fail your exam.

Over 30 million students worldwide already upgrade their learning with 91Ó°ÊÓ!

Key Concepts

These are the key concepts you need to understand to accurately answer the question.

Elasticity of Demand
Elasticity of demand is a crucial concept in understanding how price changes can influence consumer behavior. This economic concept measures the degree to which the quantity of a good demanded changes in response to a change in price. Simply put, it captures the sensitivity of consumers to price changes.
If demand is elastic, a small rise in price causes a large drop in the quantity demanded. For example, if the price of a non-essential item like luxury chocolate bar increases, consumers might readily shift to cheaper alternatives. Conversely, inelastic demand means that even a significant price hike has little impact on the quantity demanded. This scenario is often seen with necessities or goods that lack substitutes, such as life-saving medication.
  • Elastic demand: Small price change âž” Large change in quantity demanded.
  • Inelastic demand: Large price change âž” Small change in quantity demanded.
Understanding the elasticity of demand helps policymakers and businesses predict how changes in price can affect consumption and revenue.
Government Policy
Government policy can greatly influence market outcomes, particularly through interventions such as purchasing goods or regulating supply. In the scenario where the government considers buying illegal drugs to reduce their availability, the intent is clear: decrease supply to elevate prices, thereby reducing consumption. This approach hinges on the principle that higher prices dampen demand, a common goal in policies aimed at deterring consumption.
However, the effectiveness of such a policy is intimately linked to demand elasticity. When demand is inelastic, consumers do not significantly reduce their usage despite increased prices. Thus, a policy reliant on raising prices to lower consumption might falter if demand lacks significant elasticity. Policymakers must understand these nuances to craft effective interventions. Considering social and ethical implications is vital too, as government involvement in illegal markets can raise substantial moral and legal questions.
Market Equilibrium
Market equilibrium is the point at which the quantity demanded by consumers equals the quantity supplied by producers. In a balanced market, this equilibrium reflects an optimal price and quantity that benefit both consumers and producers. In the classic supply and demand model, equilibrium occurs at the intersection point of the supply curve and the demand curve.
When the government steps in to buy illegal drugs, the supply curve shifts leftwards, indicating a reduction in supply. This induced scarcity drives prices up, creating a new market equilibrium with a higher price and lower quantity than before. The new equilibrium price, if significantly higher, should ideally lower the quantity demanded, potentially reducing overall consumption. However, the success of reaching this new equilibrium, especially in reducing consumption, depends heavily on how elastic or inelastic the demand is.
Price Mechanism
The price mechanism is the process by which prices rise and fall as a result of changes in supply and demand. It plays a critical role in markets by signaling consumer preferences and resource allocation. Prices adjust to reflect shortages or surpluses in the market, guiding decisions made by buyers and sellers alike.
In the context of the government's proposal to buy illegal drugs, the hope is that by reducing supply, the price mechanism will adjust by raising prices. This increase in price acts as a signal to consumers, ideally leading to reduced consumption. It's important to note that the magnitude of this effect largely hinges on the elasticity of demand. For prices to effectively lower consumption, they must deter enough consumers. Thus, understanding how the price mechanism interacts with demand elasticity is essential for assessing the potential success of such a policy. This interconnectedness underscores the price mechanism's role as a fundamental force in economics.

One App. One Place for Learning.

All the tools & learning materials you need for study success - in one app.

Get started for free

Most popular questions from this chapter

How is each of the following events likely to shift the supply curve or the demand curve for fast-food hamburgers in the United States? Make sure you indicate which curve (curves) is affected and if it shifts out or in. a. The price of beef triples. b. The price of chicken falls by half. c. The number of teenagers in the economy falls due to an aging population. d. Mad cow disease, a rare but fatal medical condition caused by eating tainted beef, becomes common in the United States. e. The Food and Drug Administration publishes a report stating that a certain weight-loss diet, which encourages the intake of large amounts of meat, is dangerous to one's health. f. An inexpensive new grill for home use that allows consumers to make delicious hamburgers is heavily advertised on television. g. The minimum wage rises.

Suppose the demand for down pillows is given by \(Q^{D}=100-P\), and that the supply of down pillows is given by \(Q^{S}=-20+2 P\) a. Solve for the equilibrium price. b. Plug the equilibrium price back into the demand equation and solve for the equilibrium quantity. c. Double-check your work by plugging the equilibrium price back into the supply equation and solving for the equilibrium quantity. Does your answer agree with what you got in (b)? d. Solve for the elasticities of demand and supply at the equilibrium point. Which is more elastic: demand or supply? e. Invert the demand and supply functions (in other words, solve each for \(P\) ) and graph them. Do the equilibrium point and relative elasticities shown in the graph appear to coincide with your answers?

One assumption of the supply and demand model is that all goods bought and sold are identical. Why do you suppose economists commonly make this assumption? Does the supply and demand model lose its usefulness if goods are not identical?

The supply of wheat is given by the following equation: \(Q_{W}^{S}=-6+4 P_{w}-2 P_{c}-P_{f}\) where \(Q_{W}^{S}\) is the quantity of wheat supplied, in millions of bushels; \(P_{w}\) is the price of wheat per bushel; \(P_{c}\) is the price of corn per bushel; and \(P_{f}\) is the price of tractor fuel per gallon. a. Graph the inverse supply curve when corn sells for \(\$ 4\) a bushel and fuel sells for \(\$ 2\) a gallon. What is the supply choke price? b. How much wheat will be supplied at a price of \(\$ 4 ? \$ 8 ?\) c. What will happen to the supply of wheat if the price of corn increases to \(\$ 6\) per bushel? Explain intuitively; then graph the new inverse supply carefully and indicate the new choke price. d. Suppose instead that the price of corn remains \(\$ 4,\) but the price of fuel decreases to \(\$ 1 .\) What will happen to the supply of wheat as a result? Explain intuitively; then graph the new inverse supply. Be sure to indicate the new choke price.

Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies are demanded by those who wish to use them to complete transactions or those who wish to speculate on their future value. Bitcoins are supplied by thousands of competing miners who harness computing power to "dig" for Bitcoins by solving math problems. The more Bitcoins mined, the more difficult the math problems become. a. Use information in the chapter opener to explain why the supply curve of Bitcoins is likely to be upward-sloping. b. Increases in computing speed have, all else equal, made it easier for miners to mine Bitcoins. Draw a properly labeled graph showing how an increase in computing power affects the supply of Bitcoins. c. Suppose that the only change in the market for Bitcoins is the change described in (b). How would that change affect the equilibrium price and quantity of Bitcoins sold?

See all solutions

Recommended explanations on Economics Textbooks

View all explanations

What do you think about this solution?

We value your feedback to improve our textbook solutions.

Study anywhere. Anytime. Across all devices.