Problem 1 "If price were outlawed as the r... [FREE SOLUTION]

Chapter 4: Problem 1

"If price were outlawed as the rationing device used in markets, there would be no need for another rationing device to take its place. We would have reached utopia." Discuss.

Short Answer

Expert verified

Eliminating the use of price as a rationing device in markets would most likely result in the need for another rationing device rather than creating a utopian society. Alternate rationing devices can introduce new inequities and inefficiencies.

Step by step solution

Understanding the Role of Price

Price serves as an allocation mechanism in markets. In its simplest form, markets operate on supply and demand principles. When demand exceeds supply, prices rise, encouraging production and discouraging consumption until equilibrium is reached. Conversely, if supply exceeds demand, prices fall, encouraging consumption and discouraging production.

Imagining a World without Price

Without price, an alternate allocation mechanism likely becomes necessary. The problem is identifying viable non-price rationing devices. These alternate rationing devices could include queuing (first-come, first-served), lottery (random selection), or discretion (allowing suppliers to choose to whom they provide goods or services).

Assessing the Utopian Proposition

The assumption in this exercise is that the abolition of price as a rationing tool would create a utopia. However, each of the alternate rationing devices mentioned above introduces inefficiencies and potential inequity. For instance, queuing and lottery systems may lead to wasted time or resources, while discretion-based systems are prone to biased allocation. Hence, it is doubtful that eliminating price as a rationing mechanism would result in a utopian society.