Problem 7 Outline the details of the debat... [FREE SOLUTION]

Chapter 18: Problem 7

Outline the details of the debate between economists who favor a rules-based monetary policy and those who favor a discretionary monetary policy.

Short Answer

Expert verified

The debate between rules-based monetary policy and discretionary monetary policy essentially hinges on consistency and predictability versus flexibility and adaptability. Advocates of rules-based policy value the consistency and predictability it provides, while advocates of discretionary policy value the flexibility it provides in responding to dynamic and unpredictable economic conditions.

Step by step solution

Understanding Monetary Policies

Monetary policies are the plans of a government or central bank to determine the size and rate of growth of the money supply. They have two guiding principles: rules-based policy and discretionary policy. Rules-based policy is one where the central bank sets the interest rates using set formulas based on macroeconomic principles, while a discretionary policy allows the central bank to adjust monetary policy as needed.

Details of Rules-based Monetary Policy

Proponents of rules-based monetary policy argue that it provides consistency and predictability, which can lead to stability in the economy and financial markets. They believe that the policy rule can help avoid policy mistakes by restricting the central bank's ability to make decisions based on temporary or short-term conditions. They often cite the Taylor rule as an effective rule-based policy.

Details of Discretionary Monetary Policy

On the other hand, proponents of discretionary monetary policy argue that it allows for flexibility. They believe that due to the dynamism and unpredictability of the economy, the central bank needs discretion to adjust policy according to the needs of the economy. According to them, the rules may not take all factors into consideration and hence flexibility of policy change is more beneficial.

The Debate

In the debate, economists who favor rules-based policy give importance to the stability and predictability provided by rule-based monetary policy. On the other hand, economists who favor discretionary policy stress on the flexibility it provides in catering to the ever-changing economic conditions. However, both parties agree that a good monetary policy needs to be credible, predictable, transparent, and responsive to changing economic conditions and shocks.