In 2010 , a U.S. District Judge ruled to invalidate Myriad Genetics' patents
on the \(B R C A 1\) and \(B R C A 2\) genes. Judge Sweet noted that since the
genes are part of the natural world, they are not patentable. Myriad Genetics
also holds patents on the development of a direct-to-consumer test for the \(B
R C A 1\) and \(B R C A 2\) genes
(a) Would you agree with the ruling to invalidate the patenting of the \(B R C
A 1\) and \(B R C A 2\) genes? If you were asked to judge the patenting of the
direct-to-consumer test for the \(B R C A 1\) and BRCA2 genes, how would you
rule?
(b) J. Craig Venter has filed a patent application for his "firstever human-
made life form." This patent is designed to cover the genome of \(M .\)
genitalium. Would your ruling for Venter's "organism" be different from the
judge's ruling on patenting of the BRCA1 and BRCA2 genes?